The 1–0 defeat by Heidenheim on April 28, 2024 confirmed immediate relegation.
With 17 points and three games remaining, Darmstadt could reach only 26, while Mainz already had 28 in the play-off position. Relegation was therefore mathematically certain. The brief Bundesliga stay was followed by another rebuilding period in the 2. Bundesliga.
The play-off position had still been within reach before the final matchday; afterwards, Heidenheim finish seventeenth. The club’s first spell in the Bundesliga comes to an end.