Titel
Meister der Football Conference1×1986/87
Meister der Northern Counties East Football League Premier Division1×2012/13
Meister der Northern Counties East Football League Division One1×2008/09
North Riding Senior Cup24×2024/25, 2022/23, 2021/22, 2018/19, 2003/04, 1991/92, 1987/88, 1986/87, 1984/85, 1981/82, 1980/81, 1977/78, 1976/77, 1973/74, 1972/73, 1968/69, 1961/62, 1960/61, 1958/59, 1955/56, 1947/48, 1938/39, 1928/29, 1908/09
Scarborough & East Riding County Cup10×1903/04, 1901/02, 1900/01, 1896/97, 1892/93, 1891/92, 1890/91, 1888/89, 1887/88, 1885/86
FA Trophy3×1976/77, 1975/76, 1972/73
Conference League Cup1×1983/84
Northern Premier League Challenge Cup1×1976/77
North Eastern League1×1962/63
Midland League1×1929/30











