The history of Scarborough Athletic
Milestones and background from the club's history, in chronological order.
Categories
Competitions
Nicknames through the years Three names tell a story of near misses, late goals and an unbeaten season. Read the storiesClose the stories
1930–1939
A first FA Cup third round
Scarborough reached the FA Cup third round proper for the first time. The Midland League club lost narrowly, 2–1, to Grimsby Town at the Athletic Ground. It brought top-flight opposition to Scarborough.
11,162 watch the Luton tie
A crowd of 11,162 watched Scarborough draw 1–1 with Luton Town in the FA Cup third round at the Athletic Ground. It remained the old club’s attendance record. Luton won the replay at Kenilworth Road 5–1 four days later.
1970–1979
A narrow cup defeat by Crystal Palace
Scarborough returned to the FA Cup third round proper, where Crystal Palace won 2–1 at the Athletic Ground. The eventual semi-finalists ended the non-League club’s cup run, with Scarborough’s biggest success of the season still to come.
2000–2009
A first FA Cup fourth round
A 1–0 replay victory over Southend United took Scarborough into the FA Cup fourth round proper for the first time. The away tie had finished 1–1. For a club now playing in the Conference, the win set a new FA Cup milestone.
Chelsea FC return to the McCain Stadium
Chelsea FC returned to the McCain Stadium in the FA Cup. John Terry’s goal gave the Premier League side a 1–0 victory. Scarborough’s run ended in the fourth round, the old club’s best FA Cup stage.
2020–2029
Athletic reach the FA Cup proper for the first time
A 3–2 replay win at Oxford City took Scarborough Athletic into the FA Cup first round proper for the first time. The initial tie had finished 2–2. Qualification brought a home draw against Football League club Forest Green Rovers.
A record 3,209 watch the first-round debut
A club-record home crowd of 3,209 watched Scarborough Athletic draw 1–1 with Forest Green Rovers at the Flamingo Land Stadium. The club’s first FA Cup proper appearance left the tie unresolved and began an unusually prolonged contest.
The FA orders the tie to be replayed
Forest Green Rovers won the replay 5–2 but fielded an ineligible player. The FA therefore ordered the tie to be replayed at Scarborough. Athletic’s apparently completed cup run continued, with the 14 November result no longer deciding the tie.
The third match ends the cup run
The reordered match against Forest Green Rovers ended in a 4–2 defeat. After the draw, the original replay and the FA’s intervention, the tie was finally settled. Scarborough Athletic’s first appearance in the competition proper remained an important milestone.
A narrow defeat at League One Burton
Scarborough Athletic reached the FA Cup first round proper for the second consecutive season. A narrow 1–0 defeat at Burton Albion ended the run. The League One side were the highest-ranked competitive opponents the club founded in 2007 had faced.










