Trophies won

Dewar Challenge Trophy (1914–1978)Dewar Challenge Trophy (1914–1978)

Titles

U.S. Open Cup winner1×1917

Title chronology

SeasonCompetitionTrophy
1917National Challenge Cup

Final appearances without a title

SeasonCompetitionOpponent
1920National Challenge CupSt. Louis Ben Millers
1918National Challenge CupBethlehem Steel FC
1916National Challenge CupBethlehem Steel FC

Other competition achievements