Trophies won

Dewar Challenge Trophy (1914–1978)Dewar Challenge Trophy (1914–1978)

Titles

American League Cup winner7×1957/58, 1954/55, 1951/52, 1950/51, 1948/49, 1942/43, 1940/41
U.S. Open Cup winner1×1936

Title chronology

SeasonCompetitionTrophy
1957/58Lewis Cup—
1954/55Lewis Cup—
1951/52Lewis Cup—
1950/51Lewis Cup—
1948/49Lewis Cup—
1942/43Lewis Cup—
1940/41Lewis Cup—
1936National Challenge Cup

Final appearances without a title

SeasonCompetitionOpponent
1952National Challenge CupPittsburgh Harmarville
1952/53Lewis CupNewark Portuguese
1949National Challenge CupPittsburgh Morgan SC
1949/50Lewis CupNew York Americans
1939/40Lewis CupKearny Scots

Other competition achievements