Trophies won

Dewar Challenge Trophy (1914–1978)Dewar Challenge Trophy (1914–1978)

Titles

U.S. Open Cup winner4×1966, 1963, 1961, 1960
American League Cup winner1×1958/59

Title chronology

SeasonCompetitionTrophy
1966National Challenge Cup
1963National Challenge Cup
1961National Challenge Cup
1960National Challenge Cup
1958/59Lewis Cup—

Final appearances without a title

SeasonCompetitionOpponent
1964National Challenge CupLos Angeles Kickers-Victoria
1962/63Lewis CupNewark Ukrainian Sitch
1957/58Lewis CupPhiladelphia Uhrik Truckers

Other competition achievements