Titles
Title chronology
Final appearances without a title
| Season | Competition | Opponent |
|---|---|---|
| 1888/89 | Cleveland Cup | St Augustine's |
| 1885/86 | Cleveland Cup | Middlesbrough FC |
| 1884/85 | Cleveland Cup | Middlesbrough FC |
| 1883/84 | Cleveland Cup | Middlesbrough FC |
| 1882/83 | Cleveland Cup | Middlesbrough FC |
| 1881/82 | Cleveland Cup | Middlesbrough FC |
