The club won the main cup four times under the name New York Greek-American.
Historical club names of New York Greek-American
- 1967–1988Official nameNew York Greek-AmericanDisplay name: New York Greek-American
- 1989Official nameNew York Greek-American/AtlasDisplay name: New York Greek-American/Atlas
The club used the Atlas suffix in the 1989 cup final.
- since 1990Official nameNew York Greek-AmericanDisplay name: New York Greek-American
The club has again used the name New York Greek-American since 1990.