SeasonEFL Trophy winnerRunner-upTrophy
2025/26Luton TownStockport County
2024/25Peterborough UnitedBirmingham City
2023/24Peterborough UnitedWycombe Wanderers
2022/23Bolton WanderersPlymouth Argyle
2021/22Rotherham UnitedSutton United
2020/21Sunderland AFCTranmere Rovers
2019/20Salford CityPortsmouth FC
2018/19Portsmouth FCSunderland AFC
2017/18Lincoln CityShrewsbury Town
2016/17Coventry CityOxford United
2015/16
Football League Trophy
Barnsley FCOxford United
2014/15
Football League Trophy
Bristol CityWalsall
2013/14
Football League Trophy
Peterborough UnitedChesterfield FC
2012/13
Football League Trophy
Crewe AlexandraSouthend United
2011/12
Football League Trophy
Chesterfield FCSwindon Town
2010/11
Football League Trophy
Carlisle UnitedBrentford FC
2009/10
Football League Trophy
Southampton FCCarlisle United
2008/09
Football League Trophy
Luton TownScunthorpe United
2007/08
Football League Trophy
Milton Keynes DonsGrimsby Town
2006/07
Football League Trophy
Doncaster RoversBristol Rovers
2005/06
Football League Trophy
Swansea CityCarlisle United
2004/05
Football League Trophy
WrexhamSouthend United
2003/04
Football League Trophy
Blackpool FCSouthend United
2002/03
Football League Trophy
Bristol CityCarlisle United
2001/02
Football League Trophy
Blackpool FCCambridge United
2000/01
Football League Trophy
Port ValeBrentford FC
1999/00
Football League Trophy
Stoke CityBristol City
1998/99
Football League Trophy
Wigan AthleticMillwall FC
1997/98
Football League Trophy
Grimsby TownAFC Bournemouth
1996/97
Football League Trophy
Carlisle UnitedColchester United
1995/96
Football League Trophy
Rotherham UnitedShrewsbury Town
1994/95
Football League Trophy
Birmingham CityCarlisle United
1993/94
Football League Trophy
Swansea CityHuddersfield Town
1992/93
Football League Trophy
Port ValeStockport County
1991/92
Associate Members’ Cup
Stoke CityStockport County
1990/91
Associate Members’ Cup
Birmingham CityTranmere Rovers
1989/90
Associate Members’ Cup
Tranmere RoversBristol Rovers
1988/89
Associate Members’ Cup
Bolton WanderersTorquay United
1987/88
Associate Members’ Cup
Wolverhampton WanderersBurnley FC
1986/87
Associate Members’ Cup
Mansfield TownBristol City
1985/86
Associate Members’ Cup
Bristol CityBolton Wanderers
1984/85
Associate Members’ Cup
Wigan AthleticBrentford FC
1983/84
Associate Members’ Cup
AFC BournemouthHull City—