The competition links the historical NZFA Challenge Trophy editions from 1978 to 1987 with the Charity Cup season curtain-raiser staged since 2011 between the league champions and cup winners. The intervening inactive years are not counted as fictional editions.
SeasonNew Zealand Super CupRunner-upTrophy
2024Wellington OlympicChristchurch United
Final: 3–0
2023Not held
The competition was not held.
2022Not held
The competition was not held.
2021Not held
The competition was not held.
2020Auckland City FCTeam Wellington
Final: 3–1
2019Auckland City FCEastern Suburbs AFC
Final: 2–0
2018Auckland City FCTeam Wellington
Final: 4–3
2017Team WellingtonAuckland City FC
Final: 3–1
2016Auckland City FCTeam Wellington
Final: 3–1
2015Auckland City FCTeam Wellington
Final: 3–0
2014Team WellingtonAuckland City FC
Final: 2–2 (4–3 pens)
2013Auckland City FCWaitakere United
Final: 4–1
2012Waitakere UnitedAuckland City FC
Final: 2–1
2011Auckland City FCWaitakere United
Final: 3–2
1987North Shore United AFCMount Wellington AFC
Final: 3–0		—
1986Wellington UnitedNapier City Rovers
Final: 2–0		—
1985Gisborne CityManurewa AFC
Final: 1–0		—
1984Manurewa AFCMount Wellington AFC
Final: 2–1		—
1983Mount Wellington AFCNorth Shore United AFC
Final: 1–0		—
1982Wellington UnitedDunedin City
Final: 1–1 (5–4 pens)		—
1981Mount Wellington AFCGisborne City
Final: 2–0		—
1980Mount Wellington AFCNorth Shore United AFC
Final: 3–1		—
1979Not held
The competition was not held.
1978Manurewa AFCChristchurch United
Final: 2–0		—