Historical cup among first division clubs: the 1944 Malta Cup and the 1950 and 1951 Scicluna Cup. The latter two editions each had two independent sections. Later unofficial Scicluna fixtures are not a national Super Cup.
| Season | Maltese League Cup winner | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1951 Two sections | Sliema Wanderers Ħamrun Spartans FC | Valletta FC St George’s FC Independent sections: A 3-1; B 4-1 | — |
| 1950 Two sections | Sliema Wanderers Luqa St Andrew’s FC | Ħamrun Spartans FC Hibernians FC Independent sections: A 2-0; B 3-0 | — |
| 1944 Malta Cup | Valletta FC | Floriana Athletic Final: 2-1. |  |
