Super Cup between league and cup winners since 1951, originally the Pakkos Shield and from 1979 the Stilianakis Shield. The competition had several interruptions. In 1962, double winners Anorthosis received the shield without a match or a final opponent.
| Season | Cypriot Super Cup winner | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Pafos FC | Omonia Nicosia |  |
| 2025 | AEK Larnaca | Pafos FC | — |
| 2024 | APOEL Nicosia | Pafos FC | — |
| 2023 | Aris Limassol | Omonia Nicosia |  |
| 2022 | Apollon Limassol | Omonia Nicosia | |
| 2021 | Omonia Nicosia | Anorthosis Famagusta | — |
| 2020 | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 2019 | APOEL Nicosia | AEL Limassol | — |
| 2018 | AEK Larnaca | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 2017 | Apollon Limassol | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 2016 | Apollon Limassol | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 2015 | AEL Limassol | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 2014 | Ermis Aradippou | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 2013 LTV Super Cup | APOEL Nicosia | Apollon Limassol | — |
| 2012 LTV Super Cup | Omonia Nicosia | AEL Limassol | — |
| 2011 LTV Super Cup | APOEL Nicosia | Omonia Nicosia | — |
| 2010 LTV Super Cup | Omonia Nicosia | Apollon Limassol | — |
| 2009 LTV Super Cup | APOEL Nicosia | APOP Kinyras Peyias | — |
| 2008 LTV Super Cup | APOEL Nicosia | Anorthosis Famagusta | — |
| 2007 Cyprus FA Shield | Anorthosis Famagusta | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 2006 Cyprus FA Shield | Apollon Limassol | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 2005 Cyprus FA Shield | Omonia Nicosia | Anorthosis Famagusta | — |
| 2004 Cyprus FA Shield | APOEL Nicosia | AEK Larnaca | — |
| 2003 Cyprus FA Shield | Omonia Nicosia | Anorthosis Famagusta | — |
| 2002 Cyprus FA Shield | APOEL Nicosia | Anorthosis Famagusta | — |
| 2001 Cyprus FA Shield | Omonia Nicosia | Apollon Limassol | — |
| 2000 Cyprus FA Shield | Anorthosis Famagusta | Omonia Nicosia | — |
| 1999 Cyprus FA Shield | Anorthosis Famagusta | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 1998 Cyprus FA Shield | Anorthosis Famagusta | Apollon Limassol | — |
| 1997 Cyprus FA Shield | APOEL Nicosia | Anorthosis Famagusta | — |
| 1996 Cyprus FA Shield | APOEL Nicosia | AEK Larnaca | — |
| 1995 Cyprus FA Shield | Anorthosis Famagusta | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 1994 Cyprus FA Shield | Omonia Nicosia | Apollon Limassol | — |
| 1993 Cyprus FA Shield | APOEL Nicosia | Omonia Nicosia | — |
| 1992 Cyprus FA Shield | APOEL Nicosia | Apollon Limassol | — |
| 1991 Cyprus FA Shield | Omonia Nicosia | Apollon Limassol | — |
| 1990 Cyprus FA Shield | Nea Salamis Famagusta | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 1989 Cyprus FA Shield | Omonia Nicosia | AEL Limassol | — |
| 1988 Stilianakis Shield | Omonia Nicosia | Pezoporikos Larnaca | — |
| 1987 Stilianakis Shield | Omonia Nicosia | AEL Limassol | — |
| 1986 Stilianakis Shield | APOEL Nicosia | Apollon Limassol | — |
| 1985 Stilianakis Shield | AEL Limassol | Omonia Nicosia | — |
| 1984 Stilianakis Shield | APOEL Nicosia | Omonia Nicosia | — |
| 1983 Stilianakis Shield | Omonia Nicosia | Enosis Neon Paralimni | — |
| 1982 Stilianakis Shield | Omonia Nicosia | Apollon Limassol | — |
| 1981 Stilianakis Shield | Omonia Nicosia | Enosis Neon Paralimni | — |
| 1980 Stilianakis Shield | Omonia Nicosia | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 1979 Stilianakis Shield | Omonia Nicosia | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 1978 | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1977 | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1976 | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1975 | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1974 | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1973 | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1972 | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1971 | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1970 | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1969 | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1968 Pakkos Shield | AEL Limassol | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 1967 Pakkos Shield | Olympiakos Nicosia | Apollon Limassol | — |
| 1966 Pakkos Shield | Omonia Nicosia | Apollon Limassol | — |
| 1965 Pakkos Shield | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1964 Pakkos Shield | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1963 Pakkos Shield | APOEL Nicosia | Anorthosis Famagusta | — |
| 1962 Pakkos Shield | Anorthosis Famagusta | Awarded automatically Anorthosis received the shield as 1961/62 double winners without a final. | — |
| 1961 Pakkos Shield | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1960 Pakkos Shield | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1959 Pakkos Shield | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1958 Pakkos Shield | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1957 Pakkos Shield | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1956 Pakkos Shield | Not held The competition was not held. | ||
| 1955 Pakkos Shield | EPA Larnaca | AEL Limassol | — |
| 1954 Pakkos Shield | Çetinkaya Türk Spor Kulübü | Pezoporikos Larnaca | — |
| 1953 Pakkos Shield | AEL Limassol | EPA Larnaca | — |
| 1952 Pakkos Shield | Çetinkaya Türk Spor Kulübü | APOEL Nicosia | — |
| 1951 Pakkos Shield | Çetinkaya Türk Spor Kulübü | APOEL Nicosia | — |
