Historical NFL Super Cup, with several shared titles. Editions follow the trophy list; the first match was played in February 1960 between the 1959 title holders. Each joint winner receives one title, with no invented losing finalist.
| Season | NFL Champion of Champions winner | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1975 | Hellenic FC | Kaizer Chiefs | — |
| 1974 | Cape Town City FC (1960) | - Winner established; the other finalist is not reliably documented. | — |
| 1973 | Hellenic FC | - Winner established; the other finalist is not reliably documented. | — |
| 1972 | Cape Town City FC (1960) | - Winner established; the other finalist is not reliably documented. | — |
| 1971 | Cape Town City FC (1960) | - Winner established; the other finalist is not reliably documented. | — |
| 1970 | Highlands Park | - Winner established; the other finalist is not reliably documented. | — |
| 1969 | Highlands Park | - Winner established; the other finalist is not reliably documented. | — |
| 1968 | Highlands Park | - Winner established; the other finalist is not reliably documented. | — |
| 1967 | Durban United Highlands Park | - Shared title; all listed clubs are joint winners. | — |
| 1966 | Highlands Park | - Winner established; the other finalist is not reliably documented. | — |
| 1965 | Durban United | - Winner established; the other finalist is not reliably documented. | — |
| 1964 | Addington FC | - Winner established; the other finalist is not reliably documented. | — |
| 1963 | Durban City FC (1949) Germiston Callies Highlands Park | - Shared title; all listed clubs are joint winners. | — |
| 1962 | Durban City FC (1949) Highlands Park | - Shared title; all listed clubs are joint winners. | — |
| 1961 | Durban City FC (1949) | Highlands Park | — |
| 1960 | Durban City FC (1949) Johannesburg Rangers | - Shared title; all listed clubs are joint winners. | — |
