All-Ireland club competition involving both associations, first played as the Setanta Cup in 2005.
| Season | Setanta Sports Cup | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | Not held The planned 2015 edition was not held because no agreement on fixture dates was reached. The hoped-for return in 2016 did not materialise; no further titles were awarded. | ||
| 2014 Knockout competition Eight clubs entering at the quarter-finals. Two-legged knockout rounds; single-match final. | Sligo Rovers FC | Dundalk FC Final at Tallaght Stadium, Dublin on May 10, 2014: Sligo Rovers – Dundalk 1:0. | ![]() |
| 2013 Knockout competition Twelve clubs; four byes to the quarter-finals. Two-legged knockout rounds; single-match final. | Shamrock Rovers FC | Drogheda United FC Final at Tallaght Stadium, Dublin on May 11, 2013: Shamrock Rovers – Drogheda United 7:1. | ![]() |
| 2012 Knockout competition Twelve clubs; four byes to the quarter-finals. Two-legged knockout rounds; single-match final. | Crusaders FC | Derry City FC Final at The Oval, Belfast on May 12, 2012: Crusaders – Derry City 2:2 after extra time; 5:4 on penalties. | ![]() |
| 2011 Knockout competition Twelve clubs; four byes to the quarter-finals. Two-legged knockout rounds; single-match final. | Shamrock Rovers FC | Dundalk FC Final at Tallaght Stadium, Dublin on May 14, 2011: Shamrock Rovers – Dundalk 2:0. | ![]() |
| 2009/10 Groups and knockout stage Three groups of three clubs; group winners and the best runner-up reached two-legged semi-finals. Single-match final. | Bohemian FC | St Patrick’s Athletic FC Final at Tallaght Stadium, Dublin on May 15, 2010: Bohemians – St Patrick's Athletic 1:0. One 2009/10 edition, not separate tournaments in 2009 and 2010. | ![]() |
| 2008 Groups and knockout stage Two groups of four clubs; the top two in each group reached the semi-finals. Single-match final. | Cork City FC | Glentoran FC Final at Turner's Cross, Cork on November 1, 2008: Cork City – Glentoran 2:1. | ![]() |
| 2007 Groups and knockout stage Two groups of four clubs; the top two in each group reached the semi-finals. Single-match final. | Drogheda United FC | Linfield FC Final at Windsor Park, Belfast on May 12, 2007: Drogheda United – Linfield 1:1 after extra time; 4:3 on penalties. | ![]() |
| 2006 Groups and knockout stage Two groups of four clubs; the top two in each group reached the semi-finals. Single-match final. | Drogheda United FC | Cork City FC Final at Tolka Park, Dublin on April 22, 2006: Drogheda United – Cork City 1:0 after extra time (0:0 after 90 minutes). | ![]() |
| 2005 Setanta Cup Groups and knockout stage Two groups of three clubs; the group winners reached the single-match final. | Linfield FC | Shelbourne FC Final at Tolka Park, Dublin on May 21, 2005: Linfield – Shelbourne 2:0. | ![]() |












