The Sheriff of London Charity Shield, also known as the Dewar Shield, was donated by Sir Thomas Dewar and contested annually from 1898 to 1907 between a leading professional club and a leading amateur club. Proceeds supported hospitals and other charities. Corinthian FC usually represented the amateurs; Glasgow’s Queen’s Park took part in 1899. The shield was shared in 1898 and 1899. The FA Charity Shield, introduced in 1908, is a separate competition. Later fundraising matches for the original shield were held in 1931, 1932, 1934, 1964, 1965, 1966 and finally 1983, with Corinthian-Casuals replacing the former Corinthian FC from 1964. The large Mappin & Webb trophy consists of an oak panel decorated with metal reliefs and plaques.
| Season | Sheriff of London Charity Shield | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1983 Fundraising match 6–1 | Watford FC | Corinthian Casuals 28 March 1983, Vicarage Road. Match celebrating the centenary of the original Corinthian FC. Last match for the shield. | ![]() |
| 1966 Fundraising match 7–0 | Watford FC | Corinthian Casuals 3 October 1966, Vicarage Road. Fundraising match for Corinthian-Casuals. | ![]() |
| 1965 Fundraising match 5–2 | Arsenal FC | Corinthian Casuals 21 September 1965, Highbury. Fundraising match for Corinthian-Casuals. | ![]() |
| 1964 Fundraising match 7–0 | Arsenal FC | Corinthian Casuals 14 October 1964, Crystal Palace Recreation Centre. Fundraising match for Corinthian-Casuals. | ![]() |
| 1934 Fundraising match 7–4 | Tottenham Hotspur | Corinthian FC Revived fundraising match for the original shield. | ![]() |
| 1932 Fundraising match 9–2 | Arsenal FC | Corinthian FC 26 October 1932, Highbury. Revived fundraising match for the original shield. | ![]() |
| 1931 Fundraising match 5–3 | Arsenal FC | Corinthian FC 22 April 1931, Highbury. Fundraising match for the National Playing Fields Association. | ![]() |
| 1907 Final 5–2 | Newcastle United | Corinthian FC 9 March 1907. Last edition of the original annual series. | ![]() |
| 1906 Final 5–1 | Liverpool FC | Corinthian FC 28 April 1906, Craven Cottage. | ![]() |
| 1905 Final 2–1 | The Wednesday | Corinthian FC 24 April 1905, Crystal Palace. | ![]() |
| 1904 Final 10–3 | Corinthian FC | Bury FC 5 March 1904, Queen’s Club. | ![]() |
| 1903 Final 3–0 | Sunderland AFC | Corinthian FC 28 February 1903, White Hart Lane. | ![]() |
| 1902 Final 5–2 | Tottenham Hotspur | Corinthian FC 1 March 1902, White Hart Lane. | ![]() |
| 1901 Final 1–0 | Aston Villa | Corinthian FC 2 March 1901, Crystal Palace. | ![]() |
| 1899/1900 Final 2–1 | Corinthian FC | Aston Villa 8 November 1899, Crystal Palace. Edition for the 1899/1900 season. | ![]() |
| 1899 Final 0–0 after extra time | Aston Villa Queen's Park FC | Shared title 11 March 1899, Crystal Palace. Aston Villa and Queen’s Park shared the shield. Queen’s Park had beaten Corinthian 3–2 in London and 4–1 in Glasgow in the preliminary matches. | ![]() |
| 1898 Final 0–0; replay 1–1 | Corinthian FC Sheffield United | Shared title 19 March and 4 April 1898, Crystal Palace. After two draws, Corinthian and Sheffield United shared the shield. | ![]() |















