Separate award for the CPL regular-season winner. The Shield was introduced in 2023, with the 2019, 2021 and 2022 regular-season winners recognised retrospectively. No corresponding award was made for the shortened 2020 tournament.
SeasonCPL regular-season winnerTrophy
2026-—
2025Forge FC
2024Forge FC
2023Cavalry FC
2022Atlético Ottawa—
2021Forge FC—
2020Not held
No regular-season award in the shortened Island Games tournament format.
2019Cavalry FC—