Early association cup held from 1892 to 1964. Several finals required replays. In 1894 the two Lincolnshire Regiment sides shared the award.
SeasonSingapore Challenge Cup winnerRunner-upTrophy
1964Darul Afiah FCChinese Athletic
Final: 3-1.
—
1963Tan Tock Seng HospitalJunior AA
Final: 7-1.
—
1962Marine Department SCTan Tock Seng Hospital
Final: 3-2.
—
1961Chinese AthleticRoyal Air Force
Final: 5-2.
—
1960Royal Air ForceFathul Karib FC
Final: 5-0.
—
1959Darul Afiah FCFathul Karib FC
Final: 3-2.
—
1958Fathul Karib FCAmicable AA
Final: 3-1.
—
1957Amicable AAIndian Recreation Club
Final: 5-4.
—
1956Tiger SAMarine Department SC
Final: 3-2.
—
1955Marine Department SCArgonauts
Final: 3-0.
—
1954Rovers SCRoyal Navy
Final: 2-2 3-0.
—
1953Tiger SAFathul Karib FC
Final: 2-1.
—
1952Tiger SARoyal Air Force
Final: 3-0.
—
1951Royal NavyKota Raja Club
Final: 1-0.
—
1950Royal NavyRovers SC
Final: 2-1.
—
1949Kota Raja ClubBase Ordinance Depot Civilians
Final: 3-0.
—
1948Kota Raja ClubSingapore Recreation Club
Final: 3-0.
—
1947Singapore Malays Football AssociationSingapore Chinese Football Association
Final: 2-0.
—
1946Not held
1945Not held
1944Not held
1943Not held
1942Not held
1941Royal Air ForceThe Loyal Regiment
Final: 2-0.
—
1940The Loyal RegimentRoyal Air Force
Final: 1-0.
—
1939Singapore Chinese Football AssociationThe Loyal Regiment
Final: 2-1.
—
1938Royal ArtilleryRoyal Air Force
Final: 3-2.
—
1937Singapore Chinese Football Association-
Final: 2-2 3-1.
—
1936Royal ArtilleryPolice
Final: 2-0.
—
1935Singapore Chinese Football AssociationSingapore Malays Football Association
Final: 3-1.
—
1934Singapore Malays Football AssociationMarine Department SC
Final: 2-2 6-2.
—
1933Wiltshire RegimentSingapore Malays Football Association
Final: 5-3.
—
1932Singapore Malays Football AssociationRoyal Air Force
Final: 1-0.
—
1931Singapore Malays Football AssociationGloucester Regiment
Final: 4-3.
—
1930Singapore Malays Football AssociationWelch Regiment
Final: 1-0.
—
1929Singapore Cricket ClubSingapore Chinese Football Association
Final: 1-1 1-0.
—
19282nd Duke of Wellington's RegimentSingapore Chinese Football Association
Final: 4-1.
—
19272nd Duke of Wellington's RegimentSingapore Chinese Football Association
Final: 6-1.
—
19262nd Duke of Wellington's RegimentSingapore Chinese Football Association
Final: 2-1.
—
1925Singapore Chinese Football AssociationRoyal Sussex
Final: 4-2.
—
1924HMS "Pegasus"Singapore Cricket Club
Final: 2-1.
—
19232nd Battalion Middlesex RegimentSt Joseph's Old Boys
Final: 3-0.
—
19222nd Battalion Middlesex RegimentSingapore Cricket Club
Final: 1-0.
—
1921Singapore Cricket ClubRoyal Engineers
Final: 2-1.
—
19201st Battalion South StaffordshireSingapore Recreation Club
Final: 1-0.
—
1919Not held
1918Not held
19171/4th Battalion KSLISingapore Recreation Club
Final: 1-0.
—
1916Not held
1915Not held
1914King's Own Yorkshire Light InfantrySingapore Cricket Club
Final: 0-0 1-0 [2nd match after extra time].
—
1913King's Own Yorkshire Light InfantrySingapore Cricket Club
Final: 2-1.
—
1912The Buffs (East Kent Regiment)Singapore Cricket Club
Final: 2-1.
—
1911The Buffs (East Kent Regiment)Wanderers
Final: 1-0 [after extra time].
—
19103rd Battalion Middlesex Regiment-
Final: 2-0.
—
19093rd Battalion Middlesex RegimentRoyal Garrison Artillery
Final: 2-0.
—
19082nd Battalion West Kent RegimentRoyal Garrison Artillery
Final: 2-0.
—
19072nd Battalion West Kent Regiment-
Final: 1-0.
—
19061st Battery Sherwood ForestersSingapore Cricket Club
Final: 1-0.
—
19051st Battery Sherwood ForestersSingapore Cricket Club
Final: 1-0.
—
1904Harlequins1st Battalion Manchester Regiment
Final: 1-0.
—
1903Singapore Cricket ClubFort Canning Recreation Club
Final: 2-0.
—
190249th Company Royal Artillery50th Company Royal Artillery
Final: 1-0.
—
1901Singapore Cricket Club12th Company Royal Artillery
Final: 3-1.
—
190012th Company Royal Artillery35th Company Royal Artillery
Final: 0-0 1-0.
—
18991st BKOR Lancaster RegimentTanjong Pagar FC
Final: 1-0.
—
189812th Company Royal ArtilleryWest Yorkshire Regiment
Final: drawn 3-2.
—
18971st Battalion The Rifle BrigadeCorporals of The Rifle Brigade
Final: 4-0.
—
18965th North Humberland FusiliersSingapore Cricket Club
Final: 2-0.
—
1895Royal Artillery5th North Humberland Fusiliers
Final: 3-1.
—
189410th Lincolnshire RegimentShared title
The Lincolnshire Regiment first and second teams shared the award after seven drawn matches. The eleven medals were allocated by a draw among the 22 players.
—
1893Royal EngineersSingapore Cricket Club
Final: 1-0.
—
1892Singapore EngineersRoyal Artillery
Final: 2-2 6-2.
—