The Herts Senior Cup is the regional Senior Challenge Cup organised by Hertfordshire FA and has been contested since 1886–87. It was historically also known as the Herts County Cup. Professional and amateur clubs take part; professional clubs have sometimes fielded reserve or development teams. Drawn finals were formerly replayed. The finals from 1962–63 to 1966–67 were played over two legs. The competition was suspended for five seasons during the First World War but continued during the Second World War. Hemel Hempstead Town and St Albans City shared the 2019–20 title following the pandemic-related abandonment; no competition was held in 2020–21. The postponed 2024–25 final was played in July 2025.
| Season | Herts Senior Cup winners | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025/26 Final 0–0, 10–9 on penalties · 14 April 2026 · Top Field, Hitchin | Hitchin Town | Bishop's Stortford FC | — |
| 2024/25 Final 3–1 · 26 July 2025 · Focus Community Arena, Hemel Hempstead | Hemel Hempstead Town | Potters Bar Town The 2024–25 final was postponed until 26 July 2025. | ![]() |
| 2023/24 Final 4–2 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Berkhamsted FC | — |
| 2022/23 Final 2–2, 4–2 on penalties · Date not recorded | Berkhamsted FC | Hitchin Town | — |
| 2021/22 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Cheshunt FC | Hadley FC | — |
| 2020/21 Final | Not held Not held due to the COVID-19 pandemic. | ||
| 2019/20 Shared title Final not played | Hemel Hempstead Town St. Albans City | Shared title The finalists Hemel Hempstead Town and St Albans City were awarded the title jointly after the season was curtailed by the COVID-19 pandemic. | ![]() |
| 2018/19 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Boreham Wood | St. Albans City | — |
| 2017/18 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Boreham Wood | Royston Town | — |
| 2016/17 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Bishop's Stortford FC | — |
| 2015/16 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Boreham Wood | — |
| 2014/15 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Hemel Hempstead Town | Boreham Wood | — |
| 2013/14 Final 1–1 after extra time, 3–1 on penalties · Date not recorded | Boreham Wood | Bishop's Stortford FC | — |
| 2012/13 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Hemel Hempstead Town | Potters Bar Town | — |
| 2011/12 Final 7–2 · Date not recorded | Bishop's Stortford FC | Oxhey Jets | — |
| 2010/11 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Stevenage FC | — |
| 2009/10 Final 4–0 · Date not recorded | Bishop's Stortford FC | Cheshunt | — |
| 2008/09 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Stevenage Borough | Cheshunt | — |
| 2007/08 Final 5–2 · Date not recorded | Boreham Wood | Ware FC | — |
| 2006/07 Final 4–2 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Hemel Hempstead Town | — |
| 2005/06 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Bishop's Stortford FC | Stevenage Borough | — |
| 2004/05 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Boreham Wood | — |
| 2003/04 Final 4–2 · Date not recorded | Watford FC | Boreham Wood | — |
| 2002/03 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Berkhamsted Town | Cheshunt | — |
| 2001/02 Final 3–2 · Date not recorded | Boreham Wood | London Colney FC | — |
| 2000/01 Final 3–0 · Date not recorded | Baldock Town | Ware FC | — |
| 1999/00 Final 3–1 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Baldock Town | — |
| 1998/99 Final 3–2 · Date not recorded | Boreham Wood | Watford FC | — |
| 1997/98 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Watford FC | Boreham Wood | — |
| 1996/97 Final 4–1 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Boreham Wood | — |
| 1995/96 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Watford FC | — |
| 1994/95 Final 4–0 · Date not recorded | Watford FC | St. Albans City | — |
| 1993/94 Final 3–1 · Date not recorded | Watford FC | Stevenage Borough | — |
| 1992/93 Final 4–2 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Watford FC | — |
| 1991/92 Final 4–1 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Hemel Hempstead | — |
| 1990/91 Final 5–2 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Watford FC | — |
| 1989/90 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Hertford Town | St. Albans City | — |
| 1988/89 Final 5–1 · Date not recorded | Watford FC | Bishop's Stortford FC | — |
| 1987/88 Final 4–1 · Date not recorded | Watford FC | Boreham Wood | — |
| 1986/87 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Bishop's Stortford FC | Letchworth Garden City | — |
| 1985/86 Final 4–0 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Stevenage Borough | — |
| 1984/85 Final 5–2 · Date not recorded | Watford FC | Barnet FC | — |
| 1983/84 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Watford FC | Hertford Town | — |
| 1982/83 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Watford FC | Boreham Wood | — |
| 1981/82 Final 3–0 · Date not recorded | Watford FC | Hertford Town | — |
| 1980/81 Final 5–0 · Date not recorded | Watford FC | Barnet FC | — |
| 1979/80 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Boreham Wood | — |
| 1978/79 Final 3–2 after extra time · Date not recorded | Watford FC | St. Albans City | — |
| 1977/78 Final 2–1 · 08 May 1978 | Watford FC | Tring Town | — |
| 1976/77 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Bishop's Stortford FC | — |
| 1975/76 Final 3–1 · 04 May 1976 · Hitchin | Bishop's Stortford FC | Watford FC | — |
| 1974/75 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Boreham Wood | — |
| 1973/74 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Bishop's Stortford FC | Cheshunt | — |
| 1972/73 Final 2–0 after extra time · Date not recorded | Bishop's Stortford FC | Hitchin Town | — |
| 1971/72 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Boreham Wood | Cheshunt | — |
| 1970/71 Replay 1–0 · Date not recorded | Bishop's Stortford FC | St. Albans City Previous final matches: 1–1. | — |
| 1969/70 Final 1–0 after extra time · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Cheshunt | — |
| 1968/69 Final 3–2 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Cheshunt | — |
| 1967/68 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Hertford Town | — |
| 1966/67 Two-legged final Aggregate 5–4 · Date not recorded | Hertford Town | Boreham Wood Results of the two legs: 5–2 and 0–2. | — |
| 1965/66 Two-legged final Aggregate 2–1 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Hemel Hempstead Town Results of the two legs: 0–0 and 2–1. | — |
| 1964/65 Two-legged final Aggregate 5–2 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | St. Albans City Results of the two legs: 2–2 and 3–0. | — |
| 1963/64 Two-legged final Aggregate 4–3 · Date not recorded | Bishop's Stortford FC | Hertford Town Results of the two legs: 3–2 and 1–1. | — |
| 1962/63 Two-legged final Aggregate 3–2 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Hertford Town Results of the two legs: 1–1 and 2–1. | — |
| 1961/62 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Hemel Hempstead Town | — |
| 1960/61 Final 3–0 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Letchworth Town | — |
| 1959/60 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Bishop's Stortford FC | Barnet FC | — |
| 1958/59 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Bishop's Stortford FC | Barnet FC | — |
| 1957/58 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | St. Albans City | — |
| 1956/57 Final 5–1 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Hitchin Town | — |
| 1955/56 Final 4–1 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Letchworth Town | — |
| 1954/55 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Bishop's Stortford FC | — |
| 1953/54 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Ware FC | Barnet FC | — |
| 1952/53 Final 4–2 · Date not recorded | Berkhamsted Town | St. Albans City | — |
| 1951/52 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Letchworth Town | Hoddesdon Town | — |
| 1950/51 Final 3–0 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Hitchin Town | — |
| 1949/50 Final 3–1 after extra time · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Cheshunt FC | — |
| 1948/49 Final 3–1 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Cheshunt FC | — |
| 1947/48 Final 3–1 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | St. Albans City | — |
| 1946/47 Final 5–2 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Berkhamsted Town | — |
| 1945/46 Final 6–0 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | REME (Cupid Green) | — |
| 1944/45 Final 8–0 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Hitchin Town | — |
| 1943/44 Final 4–1 after extra time · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Hitchin Town | — |
| 1942/43 Final 5–1 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | St. Albans City | — |
| 1941/42 Final 3–1 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | St. Albans City | — |
| 1940/41 Final 3–2 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Leavesden Mental Hospital | — |
| 1939/40 Final 4–2 · Date not recorded | Barnet FC | Hitchin Town | — |
| 1938/39 Replay 3–0 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Leavesden Mental Hospital Previous final matches: 1–1. | — |
| 1937/38 Final 4–1 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Leavesden Mental Hospital | — |
| 1936/37 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Leavesden Mental Hospital | Apsley | — |
| 1935/36 Final 3–1 · Date not recorded | Letchworth Town | Leavesden Mental Hospital | — |
| 1934/35 Final 4–2 after extra time · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Leavesden Mental Hospital | — |
| 1933/34 Final 3–2 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Hertford Town | — |
| 1932/33 Final 3–1 · Date not recorded | Bishop's Stortford FC | Bushey United | — |
| 1931/32 Final 5–1 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Apsley | — |
| 1930/31 Replay 3–0 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Leavesden Mental Hospital Previous final matches: 0–0. | — |
| 1929/30 Final 3–2 · Date not recorded | Leavesden Mental Hospital | Apsley | — |
| 1928/29 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Apsley | — |
| 1927/28 Final 3–1 after extra time · Date not recorded | Watford Old Boys | Baldock Town | — |
| 1926/27 Final 6–4 · Date not recorded | Watford Old Boys | Ware FC | — |
| 1925/26 Final 3–1 · Date not recorded | Apsley | Cheshunt | — |
| 1924/25 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | St. Albans City | Leavesden Mental Hospital | — |
| 1923/24 Final 3–0 · Date not recorded | Cheshunt | Hoddesdon Town | — |
| 1922/23 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Blue Cross | Watford Old Boys | — |
| 1921/22 Second replay 2–0 · Date not recorded | Ware FC | Apsley Previous final matches: 3–3, 1–1. | — |
| 1920/21 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Watford Old Boys | Hitchin Blue Cross | — |
| 1919/20 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Leavesden Mental Hospital | Welwyn | — |
| 1918/19 Final | Not held Not held due to the First World War. | ||
| 1917/18 Final | Not held Not held due to the First World War. | ||
| 1916/17 Final | Not held Not held due to the First World War. | ||
| 1915/16 Final | Not held Not held due to the First World War. | ||
| 1914/15 Final | Not held Not held due to the First World War. | ||
| 1913/14 Final 4–1 · Date not recorded | Leavesden Asylum | Hitchin Union Jack | — |
| 1912/13 Final 1–0 · Date not recorded | Letchworth Athletic | Harpenden Town | — |
| 1911/12 Final 5–1 · Date not recorded | Leavesden Asylum | Hoddesdon | — |
| 1910/11 Final 3–1 · Date not recorded | Waltham Glendale | St. Albans City | — |
| 1909/10 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Hoddesdon | — |
| 1908/09 Final 3–0 · Date not recorded | Apsley | Waltham Glendale | — |
| 1907/08 Final 4–1 · Date not recorded | Apsley | Hitchin Town | — |
| 1906/07 Final 5–1 · Date not recorded | Ware FC | Hitchin Blue Cross | — |
| 1905/06 Final 4–1 · Date not recorded | Apsley | Ware FC | — |
| 1904/05 Final 3–2 · Date not recorded | Hitchin Town | Watford Victoria Works Hertfordshire FA’s historical results list records 3–2; other published summaries give 2–0. | — |
| 1903/04 Replay 3–1 · Date not recorded | Ware FC | St Albans Amateurs Previous final matches: 2–2. | — |
| 1902/03 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Hitchin | Ware FC | — |
| 1901/02 Final 4–2 · Date not recorded | St Albans Amateurs | Ware FC | — |
| 1900/01 Final Title awarded · Date not recorded | St Albans Amateurs | Stanville The final ended 1–1. Stanville failed to appear for the replay and the title was awarded to St Albans Amateurs. | — |
| 1899/00 Final 5–1 · 31 March 1900 · Watford | Hitchin | Hemel Hempstead | — |
| 1898/99 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Ware FC | Hitchin | — |
| 1897/98 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | Hitchin | Aldenham School | — |
| 1896/97 Final 2–1 · Date not recorded | West Herts | Hitchin | — |
| 1895/96 Final 3–1 · Date not recorded | Hitchin | Apsley | — |
| 1894/95 Final 2–0 · Date not recorded | Hitchin | Watford St Mary’s | — |
| 1893/94 Final 5–1 · 17 March 1894 · St Albans | West Herts | West Herts Association | — |
| 1892/93 Final 4–1 · Date not recorded | St Albans | West Herts Association | — |
| 1891/92 Final 5–2 · 02 April 1892 · Ware | Watford Rovers | Hoddesdon | — |
| 1890/91 Final 6–2 · 28 March 1891 · Hatfield | Watford Rovers | St Albans | — |
| 1889/90 Replay 5–0 · Date not recorded | Hoddesdon | St Albans Previous final matches: 3–3. | — |
| 1888/89 Final 2–0 · 23 March 1889 · St Albans | Watford Rovers | Hoddesdon | — |
| 1887/88 Final 4–3 · 17 March 1888 · Hertford | Hoddesdon | Watford Rovers | — |
| 1886/87 Final 5–2 · 26 March 1887 · Balls Park, Hertford | Hoddesdon | Watford Rovers | — |

























