Historical competition for clubs from Buenos Aires, Rosario and Montevideo, donated by Francis Hepburn Chevallier Boutell and played from 1900 to 1919.
| Season | Cup Tie Competition winner | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1919 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Boca Juniors | Club Nacional The final, played in 1920, ended Boca Juniors 2-0 Nacional. | — |
| 1918 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Montevideo Wanderers | Club Atlético Porteño Final result: Montevideo Wanderers 2-1 Porteño. | — |
| 1917 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Montevideo Wanderers | Independiente The final, played in 1918, was abandoned at 4-0 to Montevideo Wanderers and the score stood. | — |
| 1916 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | CA Peñarol | Rosario Central Final result: Peñarol 3-0 Rosario Central. | — |
| 1915 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Club Nacional | Club Atlético Porteño Final result: Nacional 2-0 Porteño. | — |
| 1914 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | River Plate | Bristol Football Club Final result: River Plate 1-0 Bristol FC. | — |
| 1913 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Club Nacional | Club Atlético de San Isidro Final result: Nacional 1-0 San Isidro. | — |
| 1912 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Club Atlético de San Isidro | Club Nacional Final result: San Isidro 1-0 Nacional. | — |
| 1911 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Montevideo Wanderers | Club Atlético de San Isidro Final result: Montevideo Wanderers 2-0 San Isidro. | — |
| 1910 Not completed No official title was awarded for this edition. | Abandoned The final between Estudiantes and CURCC stood at 2-2 after 61 minutes; the replay was never played and the competition was abandoned. | ||
| 1909 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Alumni Athletic Club | Central Uruguay Railway Cricket Club Final result: Alumni 4-0 CURCC. | — |
| 1908 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Alumni Athletic Club | Montevideo Wanderers Final result: Alumni 4-0 Montevideo Wanderers. | — |
| 1907 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Alumni Athletic Club | Central Uruguay Railway Cricket Club Final result: Alumni 3-1 CURCC. | — |
| 1906 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Alumni Athletic Club | Belgrano Athletic Club Final result: Alumni 10-1 Belgrano Athletic Club. | — |
| 1905 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Rosario Athletic Club | Central Uruguay Railway Cricket Club The final, abandoned at 4-3 after extra time, stood as a win for Rosario Athletic Club. | — |
| 1904 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Rosario Athletic Club | Central Uruguay Railway Cricket Club Final result: Rosario Athletic Club 3-2 CURCC after extra time. | — |
| 1903 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Alumni Athletic Club | Rosario Athletic Club Final result: Alumni 3-2 Rosario Athletic Club after extra time. | — |
| 1902 Final series with replays The edition was decided in the stated format. | Rosario Athletic Club | Alumni Athletic Club After two 1-1 draws, Rosario Athletic Club won the second replay 2-1 after extra time. | — |
| 1901 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Alumni Athletic Club | Central Uruguay Railway Cricket Club Final result: Alumni 1-0 CURCC. | — |
| 1900 Single-match final The edition was decided in the stated format. | Belgrano Athletic Club | Rosario Athletic Club Final result: Belgrano Athletic Club 2-0 Rosario Athletic Club. | — |
