The Cromwell Cup was played once in Sheffield in February 1868 under Sheffield rules. Local theatre manager Oliver Cromwell donated the trophy. The four entrants, The Wednesday, Garrick, Exchange and Wellington, were clubs established less than two years earlier. The Wednesday beat Garrick 1–0 after extra time at Bramall Lane on 15 February 1868. Following a goalless 90 minutes, the captains agreed to continue until a goal was scored; the winner came after about ten additional minutes. Sheffield rules also used rouges as a secondary scoring measure. This was a local tournament cup, separate from the English championship and the FA Cup. The original trophy is retained in Sheffield Wednesday’s collection.
| Season | Cromwell Cup winners | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1868 Final 1–0 after extra time | The Wednesday | Garrick Final, 15 February 1868, Bramall Lane, Sheffield: The Wednesday v Garrick 1–0 after extra time (0–0 after 90 minutes), decided by the first goal about ten minutes later. First round: 1 February, The Wednesday v Exchange 4–0 (rouges 3–0); 8 February, Garrick v Wellington 0–0 (rouges 1–0, Garrick advanced). Rouges were a separate secondary score and are not counted as goals. | ![]() |

