The Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup is the regional county cup for men’s clubs affiliated to the Sheffield & Hallamshire County FA. It began in 1876/77 as the Sheffield Challenge Cup, with The Wednesday as its first winner. Reserve sides and A teams have historically competed alongside first teams. In several early seasons the winner was decided by a final round or league format. The Invitation Cup played alongside it from 1925/26 to 1945/46 was a separate competition. The Senior Cup continues today; Worksop Town hold the record with 16 titles through 2025/26.
| Season | Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026/27 | - | - Competition in progress; the cup winner has not yet been determined. | — |
| 2025/26 Final 2–1 | Worksop Town | Worsbrough Bridge Athletic Final on 28 April 2026: Worksop Town v Worsbrough Bridge Athletic 2–1. Eco-Power Stadium. | ![]() |
| 2024/25 Final 2–1 | Worksop Town | Hallam FC Final on 8 May 2025: Worksop Town v Hallam 2–1. Hillsborough. | ![]() |
| 2023/24 Final 5–0 | Worksop Town | Penistone Church Final on 9 May 2024: Worksop Town v Penistone Church 5–0. Hillsborough. | ![]() |
| 2022/23 Final 2–0 | Emley AFC | Maltby Main Final on 20 May 2023: Emley v Maltby Main 2–0. Eco-Power Stadium. | ![]() |
| 2021/22 Final 3–0 | Worksop Town | Maltby Main Final on 30 April 2022: Worksop Town v Maltby Main 3–0. Eco-Power Stadium. | ![]() |
| 2020/21 | Not held No cup winner was determined because of the COVID-19 pandemic. | ||
| 2019/20 | Abandoned The competition was not completed because of the COVID-19 pandemic; no cup winner was determined. | ||
| 2018/19 Title award No final played | North Gawber Colliery | Awarded automatically North Gawber Colliery were awarded the cup after Frickley Athletic declined to play the final, scheduled for 23 May 2019, because of its late date. The trophy was presented at a charity match. | ![]() |
| 2017/18 Final 4–3 | Shaw Lane | Penistone Church Final: Shaw Lane v Penistone Church 4–3. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 2016/17 Final 1–0 | Shaw Lane | Frickley Athletic Final: Shaw Lane v Frickley Athletic 1–0. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 2015/16 Title award No final played | Frickley Athletic | Awarded automatically The cup was awarded to Frickley Athletic; the intended final opponent was Shaw Lane Aquaforce. No final was played. | — |
| 2014/15 Final 4–1 | Frickley Athletic | Nostell Miners Welfare Final: Frickley Athletic v Nostell Miners Welfare 4–1. New York Stadium. | — |
| 2013/14 Final 1–0 | Athersley Recreation | Frickley Athletic Final: Athersley Recreation v Frickley Athletic 1–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2012/13 Final 4–3 | Frickley Athletic | Sheffield FC Final: Frickley Athletic v Sheffield 4–3. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2011/12 Final 3–2 | Worksop Town | Frickley Athletic Final: Worksop Town v Frickley Athletic 3–2. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2010/11 Final 3–0 | Stocksbridge Park Steels | Parkgate FC Final on 3 May 2011: Stocksbridge Park Steels v Parkgate 3–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2009/10 Final 4–2 | Sheffield FC | Hallam FC Final on 4 May 2010: Sheffield v Hallam 4–2. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2008/09 Final 3–0 | Stocksbridge Park Steels | Brodsworth Welfare Final: Stocksbridge Park Steels v Brodsworth Welfare 3–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2007/08 Final 2–0 | Sheffield FC | Worksop Town Final: Sheffield v Worksop Town 2–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2006/07 Final 2–1 | Stocksbridge Park Steels | Worksop Town Final: Stocksbridge Park Steels v Worksop Town 2–1. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2005/06 Final 2–1 | Sheffield FC | Parkgate FC Final: Sheffield v Parkgate 2–1. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2004/05 Final 1–0 | Sheffield FC | Worksop Town Final: Sheffield v Worksop Town 1–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2003/04 Final 3–2 | Frickley Athletic | Worksop Town Final: Frickley Athletic v Worksop Town 3–2. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2002/03 Final 2–1 | Worksop Town | Doncaster Rovers Final: Worksop Town v Doncaster Rovers 2–1. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2001/02 Final 3–0 | Doncaster Rovers | Emley Final on 24 April 2002: Doncaster Rovers v Emley 3–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 2000/01 Final 2–1 | Doncaster Rovers | Emley Final on 9 May 2001: Doncaster Rovers v Emley 2–1. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1999/00 Final 3–0 | Frickley Athletic | Emley Final on 3 May 2000: Frickley Athletic v Emley 3–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1998/99 Final 1–0 | Stocksbridge Park Steels | Emley Final on 4 May 1999: Stocksbridge Park Steels v Emley 1–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1997/98 Final 3–0 | Emley | Parkgate FC Final on 28 April 1998: Emley v Parkgate 3–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1996/97 Final Score uncertain | Worksop Town | Harworth Colliery Institute Worksop Town won the final against Harworth Colliery Institute at Hillsborough. Result lists differ between 6–0 (FCHD) and 7–0; the exact score is uncertain. | — |
| 1995/96 Final 1–0 | Stocksbridge Park Steels | Grimethorpe Miners Welfare Final: Stocksbridge Park Steels v Grimethorpe Miners Welfare 1–0. Welfare Ground. | — |
| 1994/95 Final 1–0 | Worksop Town | Emley Final on 9 May 1995: Worksop Town v Emley 1–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1993/94 Final 1–1 aet; 6–5 pens | Sheffield FC | Worksop Town Final: Sheffield v Worksop Town 1–1 after extra time; 6–5 on penalties. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1992/93 Two-legged final 5–3 aggregate | Stocksbridge Park Steels | Worksop Town First leg: Worksop Town v Stocksbridge Park Steels 2–3. Second leg: Stocksbridge Park Steels v Worksop Town 2–1. Stocksbridge Park Steels won 5–3 on aggregate. | — |
| 1991/92 Final 1–0 | Emley | Frickley Athletic Final on 22 April 1992: Emley v Frickley Athletic 1–0. Bracken Moor. | — |
| 1990/91 Final 1–1 aet; 4–3 pens | Emley | Worksop Town Final on 12 May 1991: Emley v Worksop Town 1–1 after extra time; 4–3 on penalties. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1989/90 Two-legged final 2–1 aggregate | Frickley Athletic | Denaby United Frickley Athletic beat Denaby United 2–1 on aggregate in a two-legged final. The individual leg scores are not securely established. | — |
| 1988/89 Final 2–0 | Emley | Woolley Miners Welfare Final on 2 May 1989: Emley v Woolley Miners Welfare 2–0. Oakwell. | — |
| 1987/88 Two-legged final 2–1 aggregate | Frickley Athletic | Worksop Town First leg: Worksop Town v Frickley Athletic 1–0. Second leg: Frickley Athletic v Worksop Town 2–0. Frickley Athletic won 2–1 on aggregate. | — |
| 1986/87 Final 3–2 | Denaby United | Emley Final on 10 April 1987: Denaby United v Emley 3–2. Oakwell. | — |
| 1985/86 Final 2–0 | Frickley Athletic | Crookes Final: Frickley Athletic v Crookes 2–0. Central Avenue. | — |
| 1984/85 Final 2–1 | Worksop Town | Frickley Athletic Final: Worksop Town v Frickley Athletic 2–1. Millmoor. | — |
| 1983/84 Final 2–0 | Emley | Frecheville Community Association Final on 20 April 1984: Emley v Frecheville Community Association 2–0. Oakwell. | — |
| 1982/83 Final 3–1 | Mexborough Town Athletic | Denaby United Final: Mexborough Town Athletic v Denaby United 3–1. Millmoor. | — |
| 1981/82 Title award No final played | Worksop Town | Awarded automatically The cup was awarded to Worksop Town; the intended final opponent was Frickley Athletic. No final was played. | — |
| 1980/81 Final 2–1 | Emley | Frickley Athletic Final on 30 April 1981: Emley v Frickley Athletic 2–1. Woolley Colliery Road. | — |
| 1979/80 Final 2–0 | Emley | Worksop Town Final on 1 May 1980: Emley v Worksop Town 2–0. Oakwell. | — |
| 1978/79 Final 3–2 | Frickley Athletic | Mexborough Town Athletic Final: Frickley Athletic v Mexborough Town Athletic 3–2. Hampden Road. | — |
| 1977/78 Final 2–1 | Maltby Miners Welfare | Mexborough Town Athletic Final: Maltby Miners Welfare v Mexborough Town Athletic 2–1. Belle Vue. | — |
| 1976/77 Final 2–1 | Mexborough Town Athletic | Worksop Town Final: Mexborough Town Athletic v Worksop Town 2–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1975/76 Final 2–0 | Emley | Worksop Town Final on 4 May 1976: Emley v Worksop Town 2–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1974/75 Final 1–0 | Mexborough Town Athletic | Denaby United Final: Mexborough Town Athletic v Denaby United 1–0. Tickhill Square. | — |
| 1973/74 Final replay 2–1 | Frecheville Community Association | Worksop Town Final replay: Frecheville Community Association v Worksop Town 2–1. Hard Lane. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1972/73 Final 4–1 | Worksop Town | Worsbrough Bridge Miners Welfare Final: Worksop Town v Worsbrough Bridge Miners Welfare 4–1. Millmoor. | — |
| 1971/72 Final 3–0 | Kiveton Park | Frecheville Community Association Final: Kiveton Park v Frecheville Community Association 3–0. Swallownest. | — |
| 1970/71 Final 3–1 | Rawmarsh Welfare | Frickley Colliery Final: Rawmarsh Welfare v Frickley Colliery 3–1. Dale Road. | — |
| 1969/70 Final 2–1 | Worksop Town | Dinnington Athletic Final: Worksop Town v Dinnington Athletic 2–1. Hard Lane. | — |
| 1968/69 Final 1–0 | Redfearn Sports | Frickley Colliery Final: Redfearn Sports v Frickley Colliery 1–0. Tickhill Square. | — |
| 1967/68 Final 1–0 | Hallam FC | Norton Woodseats Final: Hallam v Norton Woodseats 1–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1966/67 Final 4–1 | Frickley Colliery | Norton Woodseats Final: Frickley Colliery v Norton Woodseats 4–1. Coach & Horses Ground. | — |
| 1965/66 Final 3–2 | Worksop Town | Frickley Colliery Final: Worksop Town v Frickley Colliery 3–2. Westfield Lane. | — |
| 1964/65 Final 3–2 | Hallam FC | Thurcroft Welfare Final: Hallam v Thurcroft Welfare 3–2. Millmoor. | — |
| 1963/64 Title award No final played | Mexborough Town | Awarded automatically The cup was awarded to Mexborough Town; the intended final opponent was Stocksbridge Works. No final was played. | — |
| 1962/63 Final 2–1 | Frickley Colliery | Sheffield United 'A' Final: Frickley Colliery v Sheffield United 'A' 2–1. Hampden Road. | — |
| 1961/62 Final replay 1–0 | Hallam FC | Sheffield FC Final replay: Hallam v Sheffield 1–0. High Green. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1960/61 Final replay 2–0 | Frickley Colliery | Worksop Town Final replay: Frickley Colliery v Worksop Town 2–0. Westfield Lane. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1959/60 Final 3–2 | Grimethorpe Miners Welfare | Denaby United Final: Grimethorpe Miners Welfare v Denaby United 3–2. Grimethorpe. | — |
| 1958/59 Final 1–0 | Bentley Colliery | Yotar Sports Final: Bentley Colliery v Yotar Sports 1–0. Tickhill Square. | — |
| 1957/58 Final 3–1 | Bentley Colliery | Stocksbridge Works Final: Bentley Colliery v Stocksbridge Works 3–1. Oakwell. | — |
| 1956/57 Final 3–2 | Frickley Colliery | Worksop Town Final: Frickley Colliery v Worksop Town 3–2. Westfield Lane. | — |
| 1955/56 Final 4–2 | Beighton Miners Welfare | Stocksbridge Works Final: Beighton Miners Welfare v Stocksbridge Works 4–2. Thorncliffe. | — |
| 1954/55 Final 2–1 | Worksop Town | Stocksbridge Works Final: Worksop Town v Stocksbridge Works 2–1. Central Avenue. | — |
| 1953/54 Final 2–1 | Sheffield Wednesday 'A' | Worksop Town Final: Sheffield Wednesday 'A' v Worksop Town 2–1. Central Avenue. | — |
| 1952/53 Final 3–1 | Worksop Town | Beighton Miners Welfare Final: Worksop Town v Beighton Miners Welfare 3–1. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1951/52 Final 4–1 | Stocksbridge Works | Denaby United Final: Stocksbridge Works v Denaby United 4–1. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1950/51 Final 3–0 | Hallam FC | Stocksbridge Works Final: Hallam v Stocksbridge Works 3–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1949/50 Final 5–3 | Upton Colliery | Beighton Miners Welfare Final: Upton Colliery v Beighton Miners Welfare 5–3. Tickhill Square. | — |
| 1948/49 Final 3–2 | Royston Social | Harworth Colliery Institute Final: Royston Social v Harworth Colliery 3–2. Central Avenue. | — |
| 1947/48 Final 1–0 | Harworth Colliery Institute | Beighton Miners Welfare Final: Harworth Colliery v Beighton Miners Welfare 1–0. Central Avenue. | — |
| 1946/47 Final Score not recorded | Thurcroft Main | Dinnington Athletic Thurcroft Main won the final against Dinnington Athletic. A numerical final score is not recorded. | — |
| 1945/46 Final 2–0 | Wombwell Athletic | Harworth Colliery Institute Final: Wombwell Athletic v Harworth Colliery 2–0. Wath. | — |
| 1944/45 Final 3–1 | Barnsley reserves | Brodsworth Welfare Final: Barnsley reserves v Brodsworth Welfare 3–1. Oakwell. | — |
| 1943/44 Final 5–3 | Royal Army Service Corps | Norton Woodseats Final: Royal Army Service Corps v Norton Woodseats 5–3. Millmoor. | — |
| 1942/43 Final replay 1–0 | Royal Army Service Corps | Sheffield Wednesday reserves Final replay: Royal Army Service Corps v Sheffield Wednesday reserves 1–0. Bramall Lane. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1941/42 Final 1–0 | Manvers Main | Sheffield United reserves Final: Manvers Main v Sheffield United reserves 1–0. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1940/41 Final replay 2–1 | South Kirkby Colliery | Beighton Miners Welfare Final replay: South Kirkby Colliery v Beighton Miners Welfare 2–1. Millmoor. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1939/40 Final replay 2–1 | Beighton Miners Welfare | Frickley Colliery Final replay: Beighton Miners Welfare v Frickley Colliery Athletic 2–1. Belle Vue. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1938/39 Final 3–2 | Rawmarsh Welfare | Worksop Town Final: Rawmarsh Welfare v Worksop Town 3–2. Beighton. | — |
| 1937/38 Final 2–1 | Norton Woodseats | Lopham Street UM Final: Norton Woodseats v Lopham Street UM 2–1. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1936/37 Final 4–3 | Upton Colliery | Thurnscoe Victoria Final: Upton Colliery v Thurnscoe Victoria 4–3. Hampden Road. | — |
| 1935/36 Final 4–2 | Denaby United | Worksop Town Final: Denaby United v Worksop Town 4–2. Central Avenue. | — |
| 1934/35 Final 3–0 | Firbeck Main Colliery | Denaby United Final: Firbeck Main Colliery v Denaby United 3–0. Dinnington. | — |
| 1933/34 Final 8–1 | Mexborough Athletic | Woodhouse Alliance Final: Mexborough Athletic v Woodhouse Alliance 8–1. Tickhill Square. | — |
| 1932/33 Final replay 1–0 | Denaby United | Rawmarsh Welfare Final replay: Denaby United v Rawmarsh Welfare 1–0. Hampden Road. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1931/32 Final 3–0 | Dinnington Athletic | South Kirkby Colliery Final: Dinnington Athletic v South Kirkby Colliery 3–0. Hampden Road. | — |
| 1930/31 Final 2–0 | Mexborough Athletic | Frickley Colliery Final: Mexborough Athletic v Frickley Colliery 2–0. Hampden Road. | — |
| 1929/30 Final replay 2–0 | South Kirkby Colliery | Cudworth Village Final replay: South Kirkby Colliery v Cudworth Village 2–0. Cemetery Road. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1928/29 Final 6–2 | Ardsley Athletic | Ecclesfield United Final: Ardsley Athletic v Ecclesfield United 6–2. Birdwell. | — |
| 1927/28 Final 3–1 | Frickley Colliery | Ardsley Athletic Final: Frickley Colliery v Ardsley Athletic 3–1. Hampden Road. | — |
| 1926/27 Final 5–2 | Darfield | Ecclesfield United Final: Darfield v Ecclesfield United 5–2. Birdwell. | — |
| 1925/26 Final 4–0 | Wath Athletic | Hemsworth West End Final: Wath Athletic v Hemsworth West End 4–0. Tickhill Square. | — |
| 1924/25 Final 5–1 | Rotherham Town | Worksop Town Final: Rotherham Town v Worksop Town 5–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1923/24 Final 3–0 | Worksop Town | Barnsley reserves Final: Worksop Town v Barnsley reserves 3–0. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1922/23 Final replay 2–0 | Wombwell | Mexborough Town Final replay: Wombwell v Mexborough Town 2–0. Wath. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1921/22 Final 2–0 | The Wednesday reserves | Barnsley reserves Final: The Wednesday reserves v Barnsley reserves 2–0. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1920/21 Final 2–0 | The Wednesday reserves | Barnsley reserves Final: The Wednesday reserves v Barnsley reserves 2–0. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1919/20 Final 1–0 | Rotherham Town | Sheffield United reserves Final: Rotherham Town v Sheffield United reserves 1–0. Clifton Lane. | — |
| 1918/19 | Not held No cup winner during the First World War. | ||
| 1917/18 | Not held No cup winner during the First World War. | ||
| 1916/17 | Not held No cup winner during the First World War. | ||
| 1915/16 | Not held No cup winner during the First World War. | ||
| 1914/15 Final 3–0 | Barnsley reserves | Worksop Town Final: Barnsley reserves v Worksop Town 3–0. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1913/14 Final 1–0 | Rotherham County | The Wednesday reserves Final: Rotherham County v The Wednesday reserves 1–0. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1912/13 Final 3–0 | Rotherham County | Worksop Town Final: Rotherham County v Worksop Town 3–0. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1911/12 Final 3–0 | Doncaster Rovers | Sheffield United reserves Final: Doncaster Rovers v Sheffield United reserves 3–0. Wath. | — |
| 1910/11 Final 4–1 | Sheffield United reserves | Mexborough Town Final: Sheffield United reserves v Mexborough Town 4–1. Clifton Lane. | — |
| 1909/10 Title award No final played | Denaby United | Awarded automatically The cup was awarded to Denaby United; the intended final opponent was Barnsley reserves. No final was played. | — |
| 1908/09 Final replay 5–1 | Sheffield United reserves | Rotherham County Final replay: Sheffield United reserves v Rotherham County 5–1. Bramall Lane. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1907/08 Final 1–0 | Sheffield United reserves | South Kirkby Colliery Final: Sheffield United reserves v South Kirkby Colliery 1–0. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1906/07 Final replay 2–0 | The Wednesday reserves | Sheffield United reserves Final replay: The Wednesday reserves v Sheffield United reserves 2–0. Bramall Lane. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1905/06 Final 4–2 | Denaby United | The Wednesday reserves Final: Denaby United v The Wednesday reserves 4–2. Clifton Lane. | — |
| 1904/05 Final 3–1 | Sheffield United reserves | The Wednesday reserves Final: Sheffield United reserves v The Wednesday reserves 3–1. Hillsborough. | — |
| 1903/04 Final 6–1 | Barnsley reserves | Hallam FC Final: Barnsley reserves v Hallam 6–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1902/03 Final replay 5–0 | The Wednesday reserves | Roundel Final replay: The Wednesday reserves v Roundel 5–0. Bramall Lane. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1901/02 Final 1–0 | The Wednesday reserves | Royston United Final: The Wednesday reserves v Royston United 1–0. Millmoor. | — |
| 1900/01 Final 6–1 | Sheffield United reserves | Channing Rovers Final: Sheffield United reserves v Channing Rovers 6–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1899/00 Final 2–0 | The Wednesday reserves | Worksop Town Final: The Wednesday reserves v Worksop Town 2–0. Carbrook. | — |
| 1898/99 Final replay 5–2 | Sheffield United reserves | Attercliffe Final replay: Sheffield United reserves v Attercliffe 5–2. Bramall Lane. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1897/98 Final 3–1 | Sheffield United reserves | The Wednesday reserves Final: Sheffield United reserves v The Wednesday reserves 3–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1896/97 Final 3–0 | Sheffield United reserves | Wath Athletic Final: Sheffield United reserves v Wath 3–0. Olive Grove. | — |
| 1895/96 League format No single final | Mexborough | Other final-round participants Sheffield United reserves The cup winner was decided by a league format. The runner-up was not a losing finalist in a single final. | — |
| 1894/95 League format No single final | The Wednesday reserves | Other final-round participants Sheffield United reserves The cup winner was decided by a league format. The runner-up was not a losing finalist in a single final. | — |
| 1893/94 League format No single final | Mexborough | Other final-round participants Sheffield United reserves The cup winner was decided by a league format. The runner-up was not a losing finalist in a single final. | — |
| 1892/93 Final 3–1 | Sheffield United reserves | The Wednesday reserves Final: Sheffield United reserves v The Wednesday reserves 3–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1891/92 Final 2–1 | Sheffield United | The Wednesday reserves Final: Sheffield United v The Wednesday reserves 2–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1890/91 Final 2–1 | Doncaster Rovers | Sheffield United Final: Doncaster Rovers v Sheffield United 2–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1889/90 Final 1–0 | Rotherham Town | Sheffield United Final: Rotherham Town v Sheffield United 1–0. Rotherham. | — |
| 1888/89 Final 2–1 | Rotherham Town | Staveley Final: Rotherham Town v Staveley 2–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1887/88 Final 3–2 | The Wednesday | Ecclesfield Final: The Wednesday v Ecclesfield 3–2. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1886/87 Final 2–1 | The Wednesday | Collegiate Final: The Wednesday v Collegiate 2–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1885/86 Final 2–1 | Mexborough | Heeley Final: Mexborough v Heeley 2–1. Old Forge Ground. | — |
| 1884/85 Final round Three semi-finals | Lockwood Brothers | Other final-round participants Park Grange The winner and runner-up were determined from three semi-finals; there was no single final. | — |
| 1883/84 Final round Three semi-finals | Lockwood Brothers | Other final-round participants Middlesbrough FC The winner and runner-up were determined from three semi-finals; there was no single final. The overall list names Middlesbrough as runner-up, while the Heeley history names Heeley. | — |
| 1882/83 Final replay 2–1 | The Wednesday | Lockwood Brothers Final replay: The Wednesday v Lockwood Brothers 2–1. Bramall Lane. The original final score is not securely established. | — |
| 1881/82 Final 5–0 | Heeley | Pyebank Final: Heeley v Pyebank 5–0. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1880/81 Final 8–1 | The Wednesday | Ecclesfield Final: The Wednesday v Ecclesfield 8–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1879/80 Final 3–1 | Staveley | Heeley Final: Staveley v Heeley 3–1. Sheaf House. | — |
| 1878/79 Final 3–1 | Thursday Wanderers | Heeley Final: Thursday Wanderers v Heeley 3–1. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1877/78 Final 2–0 | The Wednesday | Attercliffe Final: The Wednesday v Attercliffe 2–0. Bramall Lane. | — |
| 1876/77 Final 4–3 aet | The Wednesday | Heeley Final on 10 March 1877: The Wednesday v Heeley 4–3 after extra time. Bramall Lane. | — |






















