The Northern Premier League Challenge Cup was the Northern Premier League’s regional knockout league cup for its men’s clubs. First played in 1968/69, the inaugural competition was won by Bangor City. A total of 51 titles were awarded through 2018/19. Finals were initially played over two legs, then regularly at Maine Road in Manchester from 1977 to 1993 and later at various venues; two-legged finals returned from 2002 to 2005. The 1971 final also required a replay. The 2019/20 edition was abandoned because of the COVID-19 pandemic, leaving Trafford as the last winners. Sponsorship names included the UniBond League Challenge Cup, Doodson Sport Cup and Integro League Cup.
| Season | Northern Premier League Challenge Cup | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019/20 | Abandoned Abandoned because of the COVID-19 pandemic; no final was played and no title was awarded. The competition did not resume afterwards. | ||
| 2018/19 Final 2:1 | Trafford FC | Farsley Celtic Final (16 April 2019): Trafford v Farsley Celtic 2–1; Broadhurst Park. | — |
| 2017/18 Final 2:1 | Atherton Collieries | Coalville Town Final (2 May 2018): Atherton Collieries v Coalville Town 2–1; North Street. | — |
| 2016/17 Final 2:1 | Bamber Bridge FC | Grantham Town Final (19 April 2017): Bamber Bridge v Grantham Town 2–1; Harrison Park. | — |
| 2015/16 Final 2:1 | Marine FC | Scarborough Athletic Final (29 April 2016): Marine v Scarborough Athletic 2–1; Throstle Nest. | ![]() |
| 2014/15 Final 0:0; 3:2 pens | Warrington Town | Farsley AFC Final (30 April 2015): Warrington Town v Farsley AFC 0–0; Edgeley Park. Warrington Town won 3–2 on penalties. | — |
| 2013/14 Final 1:0 | AFC Fylde | Skelmersdale United Final (13 April 2014): AFC Fylde v Skelmersdale United 1–0; Edgeley Park. | — |
| 2012/13 Final 1:1 aet; 2:1 pens | North Ferriby United | Curzon Ashton Final (23 April 2013): North Ferriby United v Curzon Ashton 1–1 aet; Throstle Nest. North Ferriby United won 2–1 on penalties. | — |
| 2011/12 Final 4:1 aet | North Ferriby United | Rushall Olympic Final (28 April 2012): North Ferriby United v Rushall Olympic 4–1 aet; Coronation Park. | — |
| 2010/11 Final 1:0 | Ashton United | Northwich Victoria Final (30 April 2011): Ashton United v Northwich Victoria 1–0; Wincham Park. | — |
| 2009/10 Final 2:0 | Boston United | Retford United Final (21 April 2010): Boston United v Retford United 2–0; Ashby Avenue. | — |
| 2008/09 Final 3:2 aet | Guiseley AFC | Ilkeston Town Final: Guiseley v Ilkeston Town 3–2 aet; Tameside Stadium. | — |
| 2007/08 Final 3:0 | Eastwood Town | Skelmersdale United Final: Eastwood Town v Skelmersdale United 3–0; Tameside Stadium. | — |
| 2006/07 Final 1:0 | Fleetwood Town | Matlock Town Final (16 April 2007): Fleetwood Town v Matlock Town 1–0; Wincham Park. | — |
| 2005/06 Final 1:0 | Farsley Celtic | Stocksbridge Park Steels Final: Farsley Celtic v Stocksbridge Park Steels 1–0; Throstle Nest. | — |
| 2004/05 Final 5:3 aggregate aet | Matlock Town | Whitby Town Two-legged final: Matlock Town v Whitby Town, 5–3 on aggregate. First leg: Matlock Town v Whitby Town 2–2; Causeway Lane. Second leg: Whitby Town v Matlock Town 1–3 aet; Turnbull Ground. | — |
| 2003/04 Final 4:1 aggregate | Droylsden FC | Hucknall Town Two-legged final: Droylsden v Hucknall Town, 4–1 on aggregate. | — |
| 2002/03 Final 3:0 aggregate | Marine FC | Gateshead FC Two-legged final: Marine v Gateshead, 3–0 on aggregate. First leg on 9 April 2003: Gateshead v Marine 0–1 at Filtrona Park. Second leg on 24 April 2003: Marine v Gateshead 2–0 at Rossett Park. | — |
| 2001/02 Final 1:1 aggregate; 5:4 pens | Accrington Stanley | Bradford Park Avenue Two-legged final: Accrington Stanley v Bradford Park Avenue, 1–1 on aggregate. First leg: Bradford Park Avenue v Accrington Stanley 1–0; Horsfall Stadium. Second leg: Accrington Stanley v Bradford Park Avenue 1–0; Crown Ground. Accrington Stanley won 5–4 on penalties. | — |
| 2000/01 Final 2:2; pens | Lancaster City | Bishop Auckland FC Final: Lancaster City v Bishop Auckland 2–2; Giant Axe. Lancaster City won on penalties. | — |
| 1999/00 Final 1:0 | Lancaster City | Worksop Town Final: Lancaster City v Worksop Town 1–0; Bower Fold. | — |
| 1998/99 Final 2:1 | Stalybridge Celtic | Guiseley AFC Final: Stalybridge Celtic v Guiseley 2–1. | — |
| 1997/98 Final 2:1 | Altrincham FC | Gainsborough Trinity Final: Altrincham v Gainsborough Trinity 2–1; Saltergate. | — |
| 1996/97 Final 1:0 aet | Gainsborough Trinity | Boston United Final (29 April 1997): Gainsborough Trinity v Boston United 1–0 aet; Sincil Bank. | — |
| 1995/96 Final 1:1; pens | Hyde United | Leek Town Final: Hyde United v Leek Town 1–1; Burnden Park. Hyde United won on penalties. | — |
| 1994/95 Final 2:1 | Bamber Bridge FC | Bishop Auckland FC Final: Bamber Bridge v Bishop Auckland 2–1; Burnden Park. | — |
| 1993/94 Final 3:1 | Spennymoor United | Hyde United Final: Spennymoor United v Hyde United 3–1; Wetherby Road. | — |
| 1992/93 Final 1:1; pens | Winsford United | Warrington Town Final: Winsford United v Warrington Town 1–1; Maine Road. Winsford United won on penalties. | — |
| 1991/92 Final 1:0 | Marine FC | Frickley Athletic Final: Marine v Frickley Athletic 1–0; Maine Road. | — |
| 1990/91 Final 4:1 | Southport FC | Buxton FC Final (16 April 1991): Southport v Buxton 4–1; Maine Road. | — |
| 1989/90 Final 1:0 | Hyde United | Gateshead FC Final: Hyde United v Gateshead 1–0; Maine Road. | — |
| 1988/89 Final 2:1 | Mossley AFC | Fleetwood Town Final (18 April 1989): Mossley v Fleetwood 2–1; Maine Road. | — |
| 1987/88 Final 2:2; pens | Goole Town | Barrow AFC Final: Goole Town v Barrow 2–2; Maine Road. Goole Town won on penalties. | — |
| 1986/87 Final 2:0 | Macclesfield Town | Burton Albion Final (21 April 1987): Macclesfield Town v Burton Albion 2–0; Maine Road. | — |
| 1985/86 Final 1:0 | Hyde United | Marine FC Final: Hyde United v Marine 1–0; Maine Road. | — |
| 1984/85 Final 3:2 | Marine FC | Goole Town Final: Marine v Goole Town 3–2; Maine Road. | — |
| 1983/84 Final 1:1; pens | South Liverpool FC | Hyde United Final: South Liverpool v Hyde United 1–1; Maine Road. South Liverpool won on penalties. | — |
| 1982/83 Final 2:1 | Burton Albion | Macclesfield Town Final (19 April 1983): Burton Albion v Macclesfield Town 2–1; Maine Road. | — |
| 1981/82 Final 1:0 | Gainsborough Trinity | Mossley AFC Final (20 April 1982): Gainsborough Trinity v Mossley 1–0; Maine Road. | — |
| 1980/81 Final 4:3 | Runcorn | Marine FC Final: Runcorn v Marine 4–3; Maine Road. | — |
| 1979/80 Final 2:0 | Runcorn | Lancaster City Final: Runcorn v Lancaster City 2–0; Maine Road. | — |
| 1978/79 Final 4:1 | Mossley AFC | Northwich Victoria Final (8 May 1979): Mossley v Northwich Victoria 4–1; Maine Road. | — |
| 1977/78 Final 3:0 | Matlock Town | Boston United Final (4 May 1978): Matlock Town v Boston United 3–0; Maine Road. | — |
| 1976/77 Final 1:0 | Scarborough | Runcorn Final: Scarborough v Runcorn 1–0; Maine Road. | — |
| 1975/76 Final 5:2 aggregate | Boston United | Mossley AFC Two-legged final: Boston United v Mossley, 5–2 on aggregate. First leg (22 April 1976): Boston United v Mossley 4–0; York Street. Second leg (28 April 1976): Mossley v Boston United 2–1; Seel Park. | — |
| 1974/75 Final 2:1 aggregate | Runcorn | Stafford Rangers Two-legged final: Runcorn v Stafford Rangers, 2–1 on aggregate. First leg: Stafford Rangers v Runcorn 1–1. Second leg: Runcorn v Stafford Rangers 1–0. | — |
| 1973/74 Final 4:3 aggregate | Boston United | Altrincham FC Two-legged final: Boston United v Altrincham, 4–3 on aggregate. First leg (10 April 1974): Boston United v Altrincham 2–2. Second leg (17 April 1974): Altrincham v Boston United 1–2. | — |
| 1972/73 Final 3:2 aggregate | Northwich Victoria | Wigan Athletic Two-legged final: Northwich Victoria v Wigan Athletic, 3–2 on aggregate. | — |
| 1971/72 Final 4:2 aggregate | Wigan Athletic | Gainsborough Trinity Two-legged final: Wigan Athletic v Gainsborough Trinity, 4–2 on aggregate. | — |
| 1970/71 Final replay 1–0 in replay (1–1 aggregate before replay) | Fleetwood | Macclesfield Town Two-legged final: Fleetwood v Macclesfield Town, 1–1 on aggregate. First leg (26 April 1971): Fleetwood v Macclesfield Town 1–1; Highbury. Second leg (28 April 1971): Macclesfield Town v Fleetwood 0–0 aet; Moss Rose. Replay (7 May 1971): Fleetwood v Macclesfield Town 1–0; Springfield Park, Wigan. | — |
| 1969/70 Final 3:2 aggregate | Altrincham FC | Macclesfield Town Two-legged final: Altrincham v Macclesfield Town, 3–2 on aggregate. First leg (11 May 1970): Altrincham v Macclesfield Town 1–1. Second leg (13 May 1970): Macclesfield Town v Altrincham 1–2; Moss Rose. | — |
| 1968/69 Final 5:2 aggregate | Bangor City | Runcorn Two-legged final: Bangor City v Runcorn, 5–2 on aggregate. First leg: Bangor City v Runcorn 3–1. Second leg: Runcorn v Bangor City 1–2. | — |




















































