Early Barbadian football competition. The first edition in 1910 consisted of a league stage followed by a final; in 1934 the BAFA Cup was played alongside the Killarney Knock-out Cup.
| Season | Football Challenge Cup winner | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1934 | Kensington Rovers | - | — |
| 1928 Football Challenge Cup | Empire Club | - | — |
| 1927 Football Challenge Cup | Spartan | - | — |
| 1926 Football Challenge Cup | Empire Club | - | — |
| 1925 Football Challenge Cup | Empire Club | - | — |
| 1924 Football Challenge Cup | Empire Club | - | — |
| 1923 Football Challenge Cup | Harrison College | - | — |
| 1922 Football Challenge Cup | Kensington Rovers | - | — |
| 1921 Football Challenge Cup | Kensington Rovers | - | — |
| 1920 Football Challenge Cup | Harrison College | - | — |
| 1919 Football Challenge Cup | Kensington Rovers | - | — |
| 1918 Football Challenge Cup | Kensington Rovers | - | — |
| 1917 Football Challenge Cup | Kensington Rovers | - | — |
| 1916 Football Challenge Cup | Kensington Rovers | - | — |
| 1915 Football Challenge Cup | Kensington Rovers | - | — |
| 1914 Football Challenge Cup | Kensington Rovers | - | — |
| 1913 Football Challenge Cup | Harrison College | - | — |
| 1912 Football Challenge Cup | Kensington Rovers Harrison College | - | — |
| 1911 Football Challenge Cup | Kensington Rovers | - | — |
| 1910 Football Challenge Cup | Volunteers | Kensington Rovers | — |