DE
EN
DE
EN
BFA Shield Trophy
CONCACAF
/
Bermuda
/ BFA Shield Trophy
CONCACAF
/
Bermuda
/ BFA Shield Trophy
Cup for the second tier, now the First Division, played separately from the Premier Division Friendship Trophy.
Season
BFA Shield Trophy winner
Runner-up
Trophy
2025/26
Somerset Eagles
Robin Hood FC
—
2024/25
Boulevard Blazers
Somerset Trojans
—
2023/24
St. David's Warriors
Devonshire Colts
—
2022/23
Paget Lions
YMSC Bluebirds
—
2022
Wolves SC
YMSC Bluebirds
—
2020/21
Abandoned
The competition was abandoned without a title being awarded.
2019/20
Devonshire Colts
Flanagan’s Onions
—
2018/19
Southampton Rangers
Hamilton Parish
—
2017/18
Southampton Rangers
Paget Lions
—
2016/17
BAA Wanderers
St. George's Colts
—
2015/16
BAA Wanderers
X-Roads Warriors
—
2014/15
Devonshire Colts
YMSC Bluebirds
—
2013/14
Somerset Eagles
Devonshire Colts
—
2012/13
Hamilton Parish
Somerset Eagles
—
2011/12
Hamilton Parish
X-Roads Warriors
—
2010/11
Hamilton Parish
Wolves SC
—
2009/10
St. George's Colts
Prospect United
—
2008/09
Somerset Trojans
St. David's Warriors
—
2007/08
St. David's Warriors
Somerset Eagles
—
2006/07
Devonshire Colts
Southampton Rangers
—
2005/06
Paget Lions
X-Roads Warriors
—
2004/05
Ireland Rangers
St. David's Warriors
—
2003/04
Somerset Trojans
Paget Lions
—
2002/03
Southampton Rangers
Hamilton Parish
—
2001/02
Boulevard Blazers
Somerset Eagles
—
2000/01
Somerset Eagles
St. David's Warriors
—
1999/00
St. George's Colts
YMSC Bluebirds
—
1998/99
PHC Zebras
St. George's Colts
—