Separate tournament for the four highest-placed league clubs, with semifinals and a final. Called the President’s Cup until 2025 and BVIFA SuperCup since 2026. The league championship is awarded independently.
| Season | BVIFA SuperCup winner | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Virgin Gorda United | Panthers | ![]() |
| 2025 President's Cup | Virgin Gorda United | Wolues | — |
| 2024 President's Cup | Virgin Gorda United | Wolues | — |
| 2023 President's Cup | Wolues | Virgin Gorda United | — |
| 2022 President's Cup | Sugar Boys | Panthers | — |
| 2021 President's Cup | Islanders | Sugar Boys | — |
| 2018 President's Cup | Sugar Boys | Wolues | — |
| 2017 President's Cup | Sugar Boys | Islanders | — |





