Separate tournament for the four highest-placed league clubs, with semifinals and a final. Called the President’s Cup until 2025 and BVIFA SuperCup since 2026. The league championship is awarded independently.
SeasonBVIFA SuperCup winnerRunner-upTrophy
2026Virgin Gorda UnitedPanthers
2025
President's Cup
Virgin Gorda UnitedWolues—
2024
President's Cup
Virgin Gorda UnitedWolues—
2023
President's Cup
WoluesVirgin Gorda United—
2022
President's Cup
Sugar BoysPanthers—
2021
President's Cup
IslandersSugar Boys—
2018
President's Cup
Sugar BoysWolues—
2017
President's Cup
Sugar BoysIslanders—