Historical invitational knockout cup introduced as the Mayor’s Cup in 1999 and renamed the Hamilton Green Cup in 2017. Clubs from several regional associations and occasionally foreign guests took part. The abandoned 2003 final produced no cup winner.
| Season | Mayor’s Cup / Hamilton Green Cup winner | Runner-up | Trophy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2017 | Winners Connection FC | Guyana Police Force FC | — |
| 2016 Mayor’s Cup | Guyana Police Force FC | Western Tigers FC | — |
| 2015 Mayor’s Cup | Slingerz FC | Western Tigers FC | — |
| 2013 Mayor’s Cup | Alpha United FC | Slingerz FC | — |
| 2011 Mayor’s Cup | Camptown FC | Fruta Conquerors FC | — |
| 2010 Mayor’s Cup | Guyana Defence Force FC | Santos FC | — |
| 2009 Mayor’s Cup | Pele FC | Alpha United FC | — |
| 2008 Mayor’s Cup | Alpha United FC | Fruta Conquerors FC | — |
| 2007 Mayor’s Cup | Pele FC | Fruta Conquerors FC | — |
| 2005/06 Mayor’s Cup | Fruta Conquerors FC | Western Tigers FC | — |
| 2005 Mayor’s Cup | Pele FC | Western Tigers FC | — |
| 2003/04 Mayor’s Cup | Camptown FC | Fruta Conquerors FC | — |
| 2002/03 Mayor’s Cup | - | Camptown FC Pele FC | — |
| 2002 Mayor’s Cup | Thomas United FC | Camptown FC | — |
| 2000/01 Mayor’s Cup | Fruta Conquerors FC | Santos FC | — |
| 2000 Mayor’s Cup | Fruta Conquerors FC | Beacon FC | — |
| 1999 Mayor’s Cup | Victoria Kings FC | Thomas United FC | — |






