National professional league knockout competition first played in 2009. The Lucozade Sport Goal Shield also offered stage-dependent cash bonuses for goals scored.
SeasonLucozade Sport Goal Shield winnerRunner-upTrophy
2016Caledonia AIAW Connection
Final: Morvant Caledonia Utd. v W Connection 2–2. Penalties 4–1.
—
2014Central FCW Connection
Final: Central FC v W Connection 2–1.
2013W ConnectionNorth East Stars
Final: W Connection v North East Stars 0–0. Penalties 4–3.
—
2012Caledonia AIADefence Force
Final: Caledonia AIA v Defence Force 3–1.
—
2010North East StarsSan Juan Jabloteh
Final: North East Stars v San Juan Jabloteh 1–0.
—
2009W ConnectionDefence Force
Final: W Connection v Defence Force 3–0.
—