| Season | Winner | Runner-Up | Third Place |
|---|
| 2011 | Placencia Assassins | City Boys United | – |
| The nationwide Super League was held independently of the FFB alongside the BPFL. Both leagues joined the Premier League of Belize in late 2011. |
| 2010 | City Boys United | Nizhee Corozal | – |
| The nationwide Super League was held independently of the FFB alongside the BPFL. Both leagues joined the Premier League of Belize in late 2011. |
| 2009 | Texmar United | San Felipe Barcelona | – |
| The nationwide Super League was held independently of the FFB alongside the BPFL. Both leagues joined the Premier League of Belize in late 2011. |
| 2008/09 | Valley Renaissance | Texmar Boys | – |
| The nationwide Super League was held independently of the FFB alongside the BPFL. Both leagues joined the Premier League of Belize in late 2011. |
| 2007/08 | Texmar Boys | Benque DC United | – |
| The nationwide Super League was held independently of the FFB alongside the BPFL. Both leagues joined the Premier League of Belize in late 2011. |