SeasonWinnerRunner-UpThird Place
2025/26 Inverness Caledonian Thistle FC Stenhousemuir FC Queen of the South FC
2014/15 Greenock Morton Stranraer FC Forfar Athletic FC
2013/14 Rangers Dunfermline Athletic FC Stranraer FC
2012/13 Queen of the South FC
Scottish Football League Second Division
Alloa Athletic FC Brechin City
2011/12 Cowdenbeath FC
Scottish Football League Second Division
Arbroath FC Dumbarton FC
2010/11 Livingston FC
Scottish Football League Second Division
Ayr United FC Forfar Athletic FC
2009/10 Stirling Albion FC
Scottish Football League Second Division
Alloa Athletic FC Cowdenbeath FC
2008/09 Raith Rovers
Scottish Football League Second Division
Ayr United FC Brechin City
2007/08 Ross County FC
Scottish Football League Second Division
Airdrie United Raith Rovers
2006/07 Greenock Morton
Scottish Football League Second Division
Stirling Albion FC Raith Rovers
2005/06 Gretna FC
Scottish Football League Second Division
Greenock Morton Peterhead FC
2004/05 Brechin City
Scottish Football League Second Division
Stranraer FC Greenock Morton
2003/04 Airdrie United
Scottish Football League Second Division
Hamilton Academical FC Dumbarton FC