SeasonWinnerRunner-UpThird Place
2025/26 Lion Heart Islanders Virgin Gorda United
2024/25 Virgin Gorda United––
2023/24 Wolues––
2022/23 One Love United––
2021/22 Sugar Boys––
2021 Sugar Boys Lion Heart–
2021Title not awarded
2019/20 Islanders––
2018/19Not held
The championship was not held.
2018 One Love United––
2016/17 Islanders––
2015/16Not held
A nine-a-side tournament was played instead of an eleven-a-side championship.
2014/15Not held
A nine-a-side tournament was played instead of an eleven-a-side championship.
2014 Islanders
Premier League
––
2012/13 Islanders One Love United–
2012/13Title not awarded
2011/12 Islanders––
2010/11 Islanders––
2009/10 Islanders St Lucian Stars–
2009/10Title not awarded