SeasonWinnerRunner-UpThird Place
2025 Inter Miami CF Vancouver Whitecaps FC–
MLS Cup Final: 3–1
2024 LA Galaxy New York Red Bulls–
MLS Cup Final: 2–1
2023 Columbus Crew Los Angeles FC–
MLS Cup Final: 2–1
2022 Los Angeles FC Philadelphia Union–
MLS Cup Final: 3–3 after extra time; 3–0 on penalties
2021 New York City FC Portland Timbers–
MLS Cup Final: 1–1 after extra time; 4–2 on penalties
2020 Columbus Crew SC Seattle Sounders FC–
MLS Cup Final: 3–0
2019 Seattle Sounders FC Toronto FC–
MLS Cup Final: 3–1
2018 Atlanta United Portland Timbers–
MLS Cup Final: 2–0
2017 Toronto FC Seattle Sounders FC–
MLS Cup Final: 2–0
2016 Seattle Sounders FC Toronto FC–
MLS Cup Final: 0–0 after extra time; 5–4 on penalties
2015 Portland Timbers Columbus Crew SC–
MLS Cup Final: 2–1
2014 LA Galaxy New England Revolution–
MLS Cup Final: 2–1 after extra time
2013 Sporting Kansas City Real Salt Lake–
MLS Cup Final: 1–1 after extra time; 7–6 on penalties
2012 LA Galaxy Houston Dynamo–
MLS Cup Final: 3–1
2011 LA Galaxy Houston Dynamo–
MLS Cup Final: 1–0
2010 Colorado Rapids FC Dallas–
MLS Cup Final: 2–1 after extra time
2009 Real Salt Lake LA Galaxy–
MLS Cup Final: 1–1 after extra time; 5–4 on penalties
2008 Columbus Crew New York Red Bulls–
MLS Cup Final: 3–1
2007 Houston Dynamo New England Revolution–
MLS Cup Final: 2–1
2006 Houston Dynamo New England Revolution–
MLS Cup Final: 1–1 after extra time; 4–3 on penalties
2005 LA Galaxy New England Revolution–
MLS Cup Final: 1–0 after extra time
2004 D.C. United Kansas City Wizards–
MLS Cup Final: 3–2
2003 San Jose Earthquakes Chicago Fire–
MLS Cup Final: 4–2
2002 LA Galaxy New England Revolution–
MLS Cup Final: 1–0 after extra time
2001 San Jose Earthquakes LA Galaxy–
MLS Cup Final: 2–1 after extra time
2000 Kansas City Wizards Chicago Fire–
MLS Cup Final: 1–0
1999 D.C. United LA Galaxy–
MLS Cup Final: 2–0
1998 Chicago Fire D.C. United–
MLS Cup Final: 2–0
1997 D.C. United Colorado Rapids–
MLS Cup Final: 2–1
1996 D.C. United LA Galaxy–
MLS Cup Final: 3–2 after extra time