SeasonWinnerRunner-UpThird Place
2025/26 York City Rochdale AFC Carlisle United
2022/23 Wrexham AFC––
2021/22– Wrexham AFC–
2016/17 Lincoln City––
2014/15 Barnet FC
Conference Premier
Bristol Rovers Grimsby Town
2013/14 Luton Town
Conference Premier
Cambridge United Gateshead FC
2012/13 Mansfield Town
Conference Premier
Kidderminster Harriers Newport County
2011/12– Wrexham–
2009/10– Luton Town–
1987/88 Lincoln City
Football Conference
––
1986/87 Scarborough
Football Conference
––