SeasonWinnerRunner-UpThird Place
2025/26 Redcar Athletic Matlock Town Emley AFC
2017/18– Scarborough Athletic–
2014/15 Salford City
Northern Premier League Division One North
Darlington 1883 Bamber Bridge FC
2013/14 Curzon Ashton
Northern Premier League Division One North
Darlington 1883 Warrington Town
2012/13 Skelmersdale United
Northern Premier League Division One North
Cammell Laird New Mills AFC