SeasonWinnerRunner-UpThird Place
2025/26 Bromley FC Milton Keynes Dons Cambridge United
2023/24– Wrexham AFC–
2018/19 Lincoln City––
2017/18– Luton Town–
2016/17 Portsmouth FC––
2015/16 Northampton Town
Football League Two
Oxford United Bristol Rovers
2014/15 Burton Albion
Football League Two
Shrewsbury Town Bury FC
2013/14 Chesterfield FC
Football League Two
Scunthorpe United Rochdale AFC
2012/13 Gillingham FC
Football League Two
Rotherham United Port Vale
2011/12 Swindon Town
Football League Two
Shrewsbury Town Crawley Town
2010/11 Chesterfield FC
Football League Two
Bury FC Wycombe Wanderers
2009/10 Notts County
Football League Two
AFC Bournemouth Rochdale AFC
2008/09 Brentford FC
Football League Two
Exeter City Wycombe Wanderers
2007/08 Milton Keynes Dons
Football League Two
Peterborough United Hereford United
2006/07 Walsall
Football League Two
Hartlepool United Swindon Town
2002/03–– Wrexham
2001/02– Luton Town–
1999/00 Swansea City
Football League Third Division
––
1999/00 Brighton & Hove Albion
Football League Third Division
––
1998/99 Brentford FC
Football League Third Division
––
1992/93 Cardiff City
Football League Third Division
Wrexham–
1991/92 Burnley FC
Football League Fourth Division
––
1987/88 Wolverhampton Wanderers
Football League Fourth Division
––
1981/82 Sheffield United
Football League Fourth Division
––
1977/78 Watford FC
Football League Fourth Division
––
1975/76 Lincoln City
Football League Fourth Division
––
1969/70– Wrexham–
1967/68 Luton Town
Football League Fourth Division
––
1963/64 Brighton & Hove Albion
Football League Fourth Division
––
1962/63 Brentford FC
Football League Fourth Division
Oldham Athletic–
1961/62 Millwall FC
Football League Fourth Division
– Wrexham
1959/60–– Watford FC