The history of Scarborough Athletic
Milestones and background from the club's history, in chronological order.
Categories
Competitions
Nicknames through the years Three names tell a story of near misses, late goals and an unbeaten season. Read the storiesClose the stories
1970–1979
A first Wembley triumph
Scarborough won the FA Trophy for the first time, beating Wigan Athletic 2–1 after extra time. Colin Appleton’s side began a remarkable Wembley period which would bring four finals and three victories in five years.
Matlock end Wembley hopes
Matlock Town won Scarborough’s second FA Trophy final 4–0. It was a heavy setback on the national stage, but Scarborough would return to Wembley the following year.
A second FA Trophy
Scarborough regained the FA Trophy with a 3–2 extra-time victory over Stafford Rangers. A year after the heavy final defeat, the club responded at the same venue. Wembley again became the setting for a Scarborough title.
2010–2019
A late defeat in the League Cup final
Scarborough Athletic reached the Northern Premier League Challenge Cup final but lost 2–1 to Marine at neutral Throstle Nest in Farsley. Marine’s winner arrived in stoppage time, denying Athletic their first trophy in this competition.
Narrowly missing a first County Cup
Scarborough Athletic reached their first North Riding Senior Cup final. Middlesbrough U23 won 1–0 at the Riverside Stadium through Luke Armstrong. Scarborough played much of the second half with ten men after Sam Hewitt was sent off.
A first North Riding Senior Cup
Scarborough Athletic won the North Riding Senior Cup for the first time. A 2–2 draw with Marske United at the Riverside Stadium was followed by a 3–2 penalty-shootout victory. The cup success completed their first season in the Northern Premier League Premier Division.
2020–2029
Reaching National League North
Scarborough Athletic beat Warrington Town 2–1 in the play-off final before 2,805 spectators. Jonathan Greening’s side won promotion to National League North, returning the town to the level where Scarborough FC had played its final season.
A second success in two days
Only two days after winning promotion, Scarborough Athletic also lifted the North Riding Senior Cup. A 3–0 victory over Guisborough Town at York Community Stadium completed an exceptional first season under Jonathan Greening.
The County Cup is retained
Scarborough Athletic retained the North Riding Senior Cup with a 4–1 victory over South Park Rangers in York. After falling behind, Scarborough turned the match around before half-time and added two more goals after the interval.
A fourth North Riding Senior Cup
Scarborough Athletic won the North Riding Senior Cup for the fourth time, beating Middlesbrough U21 2–1 at the Riverside Stadium. It added to the club’s titles in 2019, 2022 and 2023.












