The history of Scarborough Athletic
Milestones and background from the club's history, in chronological order.
Categories
Competitions
Nicknames through the years Three names tell a story of near misses, late goals and an unbeaten season. Read the storiesClose the stories
1970–1979
Matlock end Wembley hopes
Matlock Town won Scarborough’s second FA Trophy final 4–0. It was a heavy setback on the national stage, but Scarborough would return to Wembley the following year.
1980–1989
Orient end the first play-off campaign
Scarborough1:0
Leyton OrientFootball League Fourth Division Second leg · May 24, 1989 · Location: Scarborough Stadium: McCain StadiumScarborough finished fifth in the Fourth Division in 1988/89, their highest Football League finish. In the subsequent play-off semi-final, Leyton Orient won the first leg 2–0 at Brisbane Road. Scarborough’s 1–0 return-leg victory at the McCain Stadium was not enough. Their first play-off campaign ended in a 2–1 aggregate defeat, ending hopes of a second promotion in three years.
Frankie Bunn scores six
The next League Cup round brought a 7–0 defeat at Oldham Athletic after the Chelsea upset. Frankie Bunn scored six goals, producing one of the competition’s most famous individual records.
1990–1999
Torquay end promotion hopes
Scarborough1:3
Torquay UnitedFootball League Third Division First leg · May 10, 1998 · Location: Scarborough Stadium: McCain StadiumSixth place took Scarborough into the 1997/98 Third Division promotion play-offs. Torquay United won the semi-final legs 3–1 at Scarborough and 4–1 at Plainmoor. A 7–2 aggregate defeat ended hopes of reaching the third tier.
2000–2009
Six-point deduction upheld
An appeal against a six-point league deduction was unsuccessful after suspended players had been fielded. It was an early administrative setback for the young supporter-owned club. Scarborough Athletic nevertheless completed their first season in fifth place.
2010–2019
The first FA Trophy run ends at Telford
Scarborough Athletic’s first FA Trophy campaign reached the third qualifying round, where higher-ranked AFC Telford United won 6–0. It ended the new Northern Premier League club’s first journey in the competition Scarborough FC had won three times.
A late defeat in the League Cup final
Scarborough Athletic reached the Northern Premier League Challenge Cup final but lost 2–1 to Marine at neutral Throstle Nest in Farsley. Marine’s winner arrived in stoppage time, denying Athletic their first trophy in this competition.
Ossett halt the promotion bid
Scarborough Athletic lost 3–1 to Ossett Town in the Division One North play-off semi-final at Queensgate. Promotion hopes ended for that season, shortly before the club began a new chapter by returning to Scarborough.
Narrowly missing a first County Cup
Scarborough Athletic reached their first North Riding Senior Cup final. Middlesbrough U23 won 1–0 at the Riverside Stadium through Luke Armstrong. Scarborough played much of the second half with ten men after Sam Hewitt was sent off.
2020–2029
The third match ends the cup run
The reordered match against Forest Green Rovers ended in a 4–2 defeat. After the draw, the original replay and the FA’s intervention, the tie was finally settled. Scarborough Athletic’s first appearance in the competition proper remained an important milestone.
The first National League North play-offs
Despite playing the season in Bridlington, Scarborough Athletic finished sixth, their best National League North position. Buxton won the opening play-off round 4–2 at Silverlands. The club’s first promotion play-off campaign at this level ended in the eliminator.








